World Democracy Manifesto

Government 101
by Benjamin Eric Kalt
“I do not know with what weapons man will fight World War III but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones.” Albert Einstein
Love of Country: Political Passions
A "Free Britain” website sums up the popular nationalist sentiment:
“This site is dedicated to those people who are fighting to keep our National Identity, fighting to preserve our right to govern our own country, make our own laws, keep our own currency, elect our own leaders; fighting to keep us from becoming a small piece of Federal Europe. In fact fighting to keep this Great Britain, unconquered for almost a thousand years, as it always has been: Free and British.”
Does it bring a tear to your eye? This outdated, pompous, tribal, bombastic war whoop is the epitome of narrow-minded national egoism - it is the epitome of the ‘othering’ that divides and threatens the EU, the UN and the world. Freedom is an absurd battle cry. Protecting freedom and the common interests is the proper purpose of the EU as well as the UN, and for that matter, government in general.
Power Struggle
The struggle for power is the heart of all politicking. Power is everything. Always self-interest fighting self-interest. Always diversity subverting agreement and common identity. Always freedom of the individual at odds with the need for unity. Always regionalization battling centralization. Always economics driving politics. Always power checking power. Perpetual power tug of war. The same tug of war takes place within and amongst all institutions: governments, corporations, businesses, schools, families, relationships and individual people. It is everywhere, it is politics, it is all too human. The United Nations does not face a new struggle, it faces the same struggle that all governments face on a larger scale - establishing legitimacy, balancing power, satisfying diverse constituencies, stabilizing volatility and protecting both its interests and its citizens.
"In essence, the conflict that exists today is no more than an old-style struggle for power, once again presented to mankind in semi-religious trappings. The difference is that, this time, the development of atomic power has imbued the struggle with a ghostly character; [all] parties know and admit that, should the quarrel deteriorate into actual war, mankind is doomed. Despite this knowledge, statesmen in responsible positions on both sides continue to employ the well-known technique of seeking to intimidate and demoralize the opponent by marshaling superior military strength. They do so even though such a policy entails the risk of war and doom. Not one statesman in a position of responsibility has dared to pursue the only course that holds out any promise of peace, the course of supranational security, since for a statesman to follow such a course would be tantamount to political suicide. Political passions, once they have been fanned into flame, exact their victims ... Citater fra..."
Albert Einstein's unfinished writing the day of his death April 18th, 1955
Intro to Government
The reluctance of governments to trust and co-operate with one another, or jurisdictionally integrate, and obey suprajurisdictional dictates, always accompanies a jump up a level of the governmental atmosphere. The power hierarchy jumps from the individual to community to municipality to nation to region/continent and finally to the world level, each level with supreme legal jurisdiction over the level beneath it, while each level has a certain sphere of powers that cannot be infringed upon by the levels above it (“Reserve Clause”). It is always in the best interests of those concerned for government to jump up a level when there is intra-level competition. Bridging divisions allows cooperation to trump competition - mutual sacrifice leads to mutual benefit. Government is the means of legitimately securing cooperation and mutual benefits for the common good. There is a very good reason why man has government.
Government 101: Centralization
The English political philosopher Thomas Hobbes' book Leviathan (1651) expounded on the 'social contract theory' of government. Hobbes contended that his theory did not fully apply to the international system because of the mediating influence of states. He said that even though states are in a hostile posture of potential war, "they still uphold the daily industry of their subjects." In other words the international state of nature does not create the day-to-day misery that would accompany a state of nature among individuals. Insecurity is not so great at the international level as at the individual level and the balance of power among states mitigates anarchy enough to allow some degree of order. Hobbes was right that the existence of states delivers individuals from the state of nature, this mitigates the urgency of the necessity of world government and makes it more intellectually elusive in international relations.
When ‘nation’ is substituted for ‘human’ the theory depicts the current international system as anarchical.
“The natural condition of nations is a state of perpetual war of all against all, where no morality exists, and everyone lives in constant fear,” this is the 'state of nature'. Hobbes’ first law states; “That every nation ought to endeavour peace as far as they have hope of obtaining it; and when they cannot obtain it, that they may seek and use all helps and advantages of war.” Hobbes explains the subtext of the political process, “We mutually divest ourselves of certain rights, such as the right to take another nation’s life, so to achieve peace. That a nation be willing, when others are so too, as far-forth as for peace and defense of his nation he shall think it necessary, to lay down this right to all things; and be contented with so much liberty against other nations, as he would allow other nations against his nation.” The mutual transferring of these rights is called a contract and is the basis of the notion of moral obligation, duty and government. From selfish reasons alone, we are both motivated to reciprocally transfer these and other obligatory rights, since this will end the dreaded state of war between us. Hobbes continues by discussing the validity of certain contracts. For example, contracts made in the state of nature are not generally binding, for, if I fear that you will violate your part of the bargain, then no true agreement can be reached. This problem is solved by giving unlimited power to a political sovereign who will punish us if we violate our contracts, “that to ensure contracts (and peace) policing power must be given to one person, or one assembly. We do this by saying, implicitly or explicitly, “I authorise and give up my right of governing myself, to this person, or to this assembly of people, on this condition, that thou give up thy right to him, and authorise all his actions in like manner.”
Survival of the fittest or competition is the law of the jungle. But in order to compete, we must first establish a framework of rules, to maintain the integrity of the game. What would soccer be without regulations and referees? What would football devolve into? The harnessing of competition is the law of civilization. When "sovereign" domains compete or overlap we hang in a limbo of tension and fear. The dilemma can only be rectified by mutually erecting a new single sphere of authority supremely encompassing all those beneath it. We must have a referee whose judgments we abide by and who can mete out meaningful consequences if we violate the rules. Arguments against one world commonwealth are arguments for anarchy, to oppose its existence one must oppose the very concept of government itself.
The American Dream
In the 1830’s a young America was divided, weak and struggling to define itself. Myopic states' righters threatened to tear the union to pieces by defying federal law, testing the legitimacy, authority and nature of the federal government. President Andrew Jackson seized the moment by boldly confronting subversive states like South Carolina (after the Ordinance of Nullification rejection of a federal tariff in 1832), and asserting federal supremacy. A loose coalition of former colonies transformed and the foundation for the unified, centralized, robust United States of America we know today was laid. A vast diverse, yet, incredibly solvent nation with an uncanny ability to absorb and incorporate any race, any belief system, any language, any culture, find common ground and somehow emerge strong, unified and amazingly, ever more American. That is the best of America: America as a microcosm of the world. Who imagines that the welfare of Americans would be improved if their nation was fragmented into fifty states, each with barriers to the movement of goods, services, capital and people from the others?
The Military Trump Card
In the spring of 2003, France and Germany, through the UN, led an attempt to stand up to the USA as a counterpoint to US world hegemony. The USA defied the UN like the state of South Carolina defied Andrew Jackson and the fledgling US federal government in the 1830’s. The U.N., however, had neither the systemic nor the military means to confront the US and enforce world law. By openly flouting and undermining the UN, the US brazenly asserted itself as the de facto world arbiter. South Carolina won. The Bush administration derided the U.N. for being incapable of dealing effectively with world crises and for lacking the gumption and teeth to face threats. The Bush administration was right. True world leadership, however, would have recognized that the U.S. was indispensable - economically, politically and, most importantly, militarily - to the task of correcting what it criticized and thereby fully legitimizing the UN as the world governing body. Today UN reform is inching forward, battling popular reluctance, nationalism and entrenched power structures. Anything short of substantive, rapid and sweeping reform represents a failure of the UN to realize its proper role and assert its unique legitimacy to govern the world and ease mounting global problems and tension.
Population Explosion and Tension
The addition of 80 million people each year to an already overcrowded globe is exacerbating the problems of water and energy shortages, pollution, desertification/loss of forests, underemployment, epidemics (AIDS), and famine. Because of their own internal problems and priorities, developed nations devote insufficient resources to deal effectively with the poorer areas of the world, which are becoming further marginalized. Recent major successful terrorist attacks on western interests have created another threat to global prosperity, illustrated, for example, by the reallocation of resources away from investment to anti-terrorist programs, wars and/or occupations which, in turn, could inflame ever larger numbers of terrorists and engender an escalating cycle of violence (CIA Factbook). The world population is over 6.4 billion strong. That’s a lot of strength, but it is a lot of weakness and volatility if it is disorganized and at odds with itself. A sustainable world governmental model holds the hope of the future of the human race.
Neo-Politics
The nation-state, as a bedrock economic-political institution, is steadily lowering barriers to international flows of people, goods, funds, and technology and central governments are steadily ceding decision-making powers to international bodies. Foremost among these, the WTO, with the principles of non-discrimination and the teeth of sanctions, seems the most likely integrator of states into the global economy. That being said the nation-state remains the most important reservoir of identity, as well as the greatest guarantor of a fairly regulated, competitive market economy. Given the current pace of global integration and the failure of many governments to embrace globalization, dispelling myths about the evil of corporations, their abuse of workers' rights, their destruction of the environment and their political omnipotence becomes ever more critical. If corporations get bad publicity their revenues can plummet overnight, but governments survive bad publicity for decades. Governments have monopoly power to tax, raise an army, and, so long as they are not integrated into the world economy, they have unchecked coercive physical power over their people. Corporations, on the other hand, rely on voluntary transactions and the value of their brand names (which can deteriorate quickly if quality falls), and are thus incalculably weaker in terms of forcing anyone to do anything (provided they are not a monopoly). To be clear, corporations are hugely powerful, more powerful than many states, what is important is not succumbing the GDP argument (that Wal-Mart's revenues are greater than Israel's GDP so Wal-Mart is more powerful). Corporations must be regulated wisely with an eye toward overall development.
Workers' rights regulations serve only to help the few employed in a given factory, for example, at the expense of those who do not. Until there is full employment in an economy, all workers' rights laws do is help the people who have jobs at the expense of those who do not. By forcing factory owners to raise wages you decrease the possibility that they will open more factories with the profits. A simple study of the miraculous Chinese economy, driven by manufacturing, shows that millions can be lifted from poverty through the pejorative sweatshops. A similar howl of outrage condemns child labor. But simply making a law prohibiting does nothing to help that child, that boy simply gets fired from his job. Where do you think he will go after getting fired? Quite likely, to a less well-paid and possibly more dangerous job. A more effective might entail paying parents of child laborers their child's lost wages in exchange for the child's attendance at school. Finally, the environmental charges cannot be blamed upon the corporations, they are profit-driven entities, the blame must fall on governments, they are charged with promoting the public good. And if you are lucky enough to live in a democratic country, the more you can hold your government accountable for good governance the more you are contributing to the democratic process which builds quality nations.
Government 102: Fragmentation
As populations grow, jurisdictions grow, and the range of problems that the government is expected to deal with increases, and its capacity to solve them is reduced. The answer to this problem of governability is given to us by the universal and healthy ‘ratchet-like’ political trend: Fragmentation. Fragmentation is the product of the demise of governability in swollen jurisdictions. Today, central governments often see control over resources slipping as separatist regional movements - typically based on ethnicity or religion - gain momentum, e.g., in the former Yugoslavia, in the former Soviet bloc, in India, in Iraq, in Indonesia, and in Canada (CIA Factbook). Unstable political units must fragment into smaller more stable, and generally more homogeneous (linguistically, religiously, culturally, racially) self-determined or semi-autonomous regional units. Some borders must be redrawn and some new nations must be born. Some will gasp at this notion but the fact is that this process has been perpetually underway, generally through violent conflict rather than prudent governmental planning, for all of modern history.
This introductory lecture on government is exactly what is inspired by analysis of the world’s allegedly daunting governmental challenges. Economic, political and cultural differences present significant challenges. The Arab-Israeli conflict, the question of Taiwanese independence from China, the struggle for the Kashmir region between India and Pakistan, the continued division of the Korean peninsula and Russia’s hold on Chechnya all represent daunting challenges involving potentially hostile nuclear powers all of which could be more effectively pacified with a world government. The world is ready. The mass opposition is rooted in nationalism, xenophobia, racism, parochial tunnel vision and fundamental misconceptions of government.
Deliberately, the straight-forward mechanics and obvious points of contention between and within the prospective member states that obstruct the path have been avoided, because it is exactly that perspective that distorts the larger context and uncorks a range of dubious prejudices and misunderstandings of the issues involved - and a general pessimism. Attempting to understand global governmental integration by analyzing the mechanistic challenges and particular points of policy dispute is like trying to understand a movie by analyzing the particular pixels of its screen. We must take a step back to see the big picture. A unified, centralized, supreme, appropriately fragmented, representative federal world government, according to the principle subsidiarity (the lowest or most local competent authority possible) not unlike the U.S. Constitution's 10th amendment's “reserve clause”), is the inevitable product of governmental evolution. In the wake of World War I Woodrow Wilson formed the League of Nations, the deficiencies of which engendered World War II. In the wake of WWII came the United Nations, either we wait for the aftermath of a 3rd World War or we seize the moment with the moxie and grit to build a legitimate, supreme world governing body today.
The Spanish Constitution may serve as a constitution for a stable world democracy, “The constitution is based on the indissoluble unity … and indivisible country of all … and recognizes and guarantees the right to autonomy of the nationalities and regions of which it is comprised and solidarity amongst them.” How we mediate by default or design between these contrary forces will determine the fate of our human race. At bottom, for peace and prosperity, we must reconcile the tension between global markets and local identity, we must embrace the words of Socrates, "I am not an Athenian or Greek but a citizen of the world."
The banner of "democracy" must then be tucked away, because it is the nationalism, empowered by democracy, that blocks the escape from anarchy. Any head of state of a nuclear power who championed a step-by-step handover of that country's nuclear arsenal to the UN, with other nuclear powers following suit, would be butchered in any general election by an opportunistic nationalist candidate. The virtues of democracy are exactly makes the realization of a world government impossible. The rallying cry of democracy must be abandoned in favor of world citizens bill of rights and the rule of law, the UN then must transform itself from an advisory peace-keeping body into the enforcer of international law.
“Mankind’s desire for peace can be realized only by the creation of a world government" Albert Einstein
Comments