Economics of Non-Proliferation?
"I do not know with what weapons World War III will be fought but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones" Einstein
Strong US allies Israel, India and Pakistan have already sidestepped the NPT. North Korea seems content with perpetual nuclear brinksmanship as its program rolls on and the South is intrigued by the possibility of absorbing its bombs. A surge in oil prices gave Iran the swagger to restart enrichment.
Why has the NPT failed in these countries?
The fact is that the NPT itself is based on a naive notion. Possessing nuclear weapons is the surest shortcut to becoming a world power. No treaty can change that fact.
Game theory 101 says cooperating (adhering to the treaty) is strictly dominated by defecting (violating the treaty), so the only possible equilibrium is for all nations to defect. In any situation defecting is more beneficial than cooperating so all rational nations will defect.
Even if The US buys off North Korea with multiple light-water reactors it will still be in North Korea's interest to secretly continue its nuclear program. Even if Iran links up with Russia it will still be in their interest to maintain a clandestine program at home.
So is that it? Are we all doomed? Why do some countries, Canada for example, have the technology but appear content without nuclear weapons? Are Canada and Iran playing the same game?
Game theory assumes that all nations are predominantly controlled by self-interest.
Bill Clinton argued, "we must show them it is in their interest [to not pursue nuclear weapons]." "Showing" implies that possessing nuclear weapons is not really in their interest but they are just too dumb to realize it. I don't buy it. Possessing nuclear weapons is in their interest, it gives them incredible leverage in the current international framework that they wouldn't have otherwise.
Maybe we have to change the game.
Basic game theory goes on to introduce a new possibility if the game is to be played repeatedly. Each nation then has an opportunity to "punish" other nations for previous non-cooperative play. The incentive to cheat may be overcome by the threat of punishment, leading to the possibility of a cooperative outcome.
Punishing a nuclear power militarily (without taking out their entire nuclear arsenal in one fell swoop) invites nuclear holocaust and mutually assured destruction. Economic punishment (sanctions) has historically proven to be less than successful towards end goals. So punishment, of any kind, while it may give a sense of moral satisfaction and self-righteousness doesn't seem to hold much promise either.
It is the fool's work to try to convince any nation to do what is not in their interest.
Any good school teacher running a classroom knows that positively reinforcing good behavior works better than punishing bad behavior. Globalization can change the rules of the game by enmeshing nations in the global economy and positively reinforcing behavior that leads to stability, peace and prosperity.
Globalization and the prosperity it can bring is the carrot.
The US-India nuclear deal is not consistent with Washington's policy towards Iran and North Korea because India is already sold on globalization, stability and peace (yes, even over Kashmir). North Korea and Iran clearly are not, they're cost-benefit analyses include the psychological value of resistance and the political utility of an external enemy) so they are playing a different game and should be treated differently. By a not dissimilar rationale, China was let in to the WTO and nudged down the path of globalization, despite human rights abuses.
Limiting proliferation through the threat of force can work (like with Gaddafi in Libya shitting his pants watching the US go after Saddam), meaning Gaddafi genuinely feared his regime and his life were in danger. But can the same strategy succeed with Iran? Is the US serious about regime change in Iran? Does Ayattollah Khamenei fear for his regime and his life? It is hard to believe any US administration would be able to sell a regime change war in Iran to the American people after the Iraq war. Of course proliferation itself is not the problem. It is a tough pill to swallow but we will just have to find a way to get used to proliferation, there may eventually be 10, 12, 15 nuclear powers. I am not suggesting we give up altogether on attempts to stop/limit proliferation but merely that we understand the economics involved that often thwart our success and adapt our approach accordingly.
Besides, the Iranians will never ever ever be convinced (nor should they) that Israel has a right to the bomb and they do not. The US can try to wage a propaganda war against Iran that casts it as a pariah, criminal state but 120 nations of the non-aligned movement, in the Tehran Declaration, supported Iran's right to a full nuclear cycle, meaning enrichment, which the US and Israel vehemently oppose. The US and Israel, even with Europe on board, can only disingenuously claim that their views represent the will of the "international community."
It must be remembered, actually using the weapons is the real concern.
Admittedly it sends the wrong message to other aspiring nuclear powers but the fact is once you have nuclear weapons the stick is out of the question and all it does is block the road to globalization which is the greatest safeguard against actually using the weapons.
India has been behaving well lately so they get a carrot and a pat on the head. The stick of threats and sanctions are ultimately just posturing. What has been gained from the endless negotiations with North Korea and Iran? What have all the efforts amounted to? Why are we not concerned about Russia and China's nuclear arsenals but we are desperate to stop North Korea and Iran? Because Russia and China are becoming more globalized everyday. In the long term carrots are our only hope. In the long-term global integration is the new undisputed holy grail of world politics.

Comments