Kerry's "Botched Joke"

Talking to college students in California, Kerry said if young people worked hard, studied and did their homework they would get ahead. "If you don't you get stuck in Iraq," he added. The headline everywhere has been "botched joke." I do not believe it was a botched joke. I think that is exactly what Kerry meant and moreover I think he is right. I have said more or less the same thing literally hundreds of times. In America, the vast majority of cadets are in the military because they couldn't find anything better. Of course I am not a senator, and he should be held to a little higher standard.
The Republicans point is valid. If I were a soldier in Iraq I might be insulted and offended by what Kerry said, though I'd hope I'd see past that to realize that Kerry was at least partially right and I believe the vast majority of them do feel they are "stuck in Iraq." Only the most gung-ho of soldiers who are 100% sold on the war effort would be outraged. And while the notion that Kerry wanted to insult the troops is laughable, that doesn't really matter. His comments, nevertheless, evidence a lack of respect for military service, a condescending, slightly paternalistic attitude towards soldiers and an assumption that nobody joins the military just because they believe in the nobility of fighting for your country. I am guilty of all the same charges. That being said, the amount of media attention this has received is excessive but essentially Kerry didn't foresee the full implications of a remark (it was NOT a joke) and said something offensive that belies his Ivy League elitism and Republicans jumped all over him.
The fact that he chose "get stuck" was presumably aimed at the fact that many troops have had their tours extended, in some cases multiple times and that America is undeniably, "stuck" in Iraq. That was his point, his clumsy delivery gave Republicans a golden nugget and they seized it, Democrats belly-aching is disingenuous, they should grudgingly cede the point and wait for it to blow over, it was a mistake, but what did they expect? In politics what you say matters, not what you (claimed to have) intended to say.
Comments