Foster Care in America and New York



There is nothing in the kingdom of nature more helpless, vulnerable and dependent on others than an infant human child – and perhaps no issue strikes a more piercing moral note in America nor rouses more compassion than child welfare. Foster care is intended to provide, usually in an urgent situation, a temporary home and care for minor children or young people who are not living with their parents or normal caregivers in order that either reunification with parent or guardian or another suitable permanent living arrangement can be facilitated. This may include an adoptive home, guardianship, or placement with a relative.
In voluntary foster care, the parents or caregivers are unable or unwilling to provide care and voluntarily and permanently give up all parental rights, transferring “custody and guardianship” of the young person to an authorized agency. For instance, a child might have behavioral problems requiring specialized treatment or the parent(s) might be experiencing serious medical, emotional, and/or financial problems that lead them to sign a voluntary placement agreement. An involuntary placement occurs when a child has been abused or neglected (or may be at risk of abuse or neglect) by his or her parent or someone else in the household, or because a court has determined that the child is a “person in need of supervision” or a juvenile delinquent. The court orders the child removed from the home for his or her safety/well-being and determines the length of the placement. Responsibility for the young person is then assumed by the relevant authority and the placement is monitored until the biological family can provide appropriate care or the biological parental rights are terminated and the child is adopted.
Family foster care can respond to unique individual needs, promote the emotional and psychological health of the child and create nurturing family relationships and is therefore seen as an improvement on, and rejection of the acceptability, of facilities known as “orphanages.” This paper will look at child welfare in America and specifically in New York; its history and current implementation at the state, federal and municipal levels as well as the overlapping issues of education, abuse, and aging out of the system, among others.

Policy Background of Child Welfare in America and New York
In 1806, the New York Orphan Asylum Society established an orphanage which set the example for many that followed nationwide. Children were given moral instruction and got clean linen and clothes regularly, and no physical punishment could be used on the children except by the orphanage’s director. In 1853, the New York Children’s Aid Society saw many orphaned, immigrant children on the streets of New York and believed that more humane treatment would appeal to good hearted people. The Society’s director set out on several trips west, with "Orphan Trains" full of children trying to find suitable parents. Thus began the early efforts to screen potential foster or adoptive parents. In 1866 in Ohio, the first government-funded children’s home was established and other states soon followed suit, including New York. Most of the above efforts were aimed primarily at care for “orphaned” children. A child remained the property of his or her parents.
In 1875 a child taken from a charitable institution into a family’ home was discovered to have been badly beaten. After receiving no help from the police, a plea was made to the New York Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (SPCA), stating that the child was an animal in need of protection. The SPCA investigated, and took the case to court. The guardian was sentenced to jail and the child was moved to state custody. With this, the New York SPCA incorporated child protective services. Other SPCAs and organizations followed suit, and more laws were written to protect children from abuse, neglect and corporal punishment. Decades later came a Children’s Bill of Rights and a number of child labor laws.
By the late ‘60s, foster homes had to go through a study and licensing procedure, and children had to be visited regularly in their placements. In the ‘70s, the reporting laws and expectations for investigating the abuse or neglect of children became more clear. The legal pendulum, however, seemed to be turning toward the rights of parents and most thought that children should remain with their families whenever possible. In the ‘80s, intensive home-based services became popular as a means of preserving the family, thereby preventing foster placement.
In the ‘90s, the rights of biological parents and the preservation of the family remained an important objective, but the child’s safety was re-emphasized as the primary objective. By the mid 90s, the number of children in the system reached an all-time high, doubling in just two decades. Deficiencies in the system, such as: unqualified/untrained social service workers, a lack of incentives for adopting children with special needs, inadequate foster parent-agency communication and, most importantly, too many children languishing for years within a, supposedly temporary foster care system – drew public attention and growing pressure for reform.
In New York City the situation was particularly dire. In 1991, partly due to a crack epidemic, the city put over 49,000 children in foster care through private agencies that were largely unaccountable to the public. In 1993, the Giuliani Administration responded to the crisis by experimenting with financial reform in six agencies (out of 36 citywide); eliminating funding based on the number of days a child spends in care in favor of giving agencies fixed payments per child served, no matter how long the child stayed in foster care. That program was discontinued a few years later due to a variety of political and financial reasons, as was a similar Giuliani program. Opponents argued that the new funding scheme financially pressured agencies to push children out of foster care before their families were strong or stable enough to care for them and would discourage agencies from taking more difficult kids because they would be more expensive to care for in terms of days of care and services required. In 1995, following public outrage towards the city’s child protective agency at the murder of 6 year-old Elisa Izquierdo by her mother, Giuliani began to focus more on children’s issues. In 1996, a major revamping eliminated the Child Welfare Administration and created a new department, the Administration for Children’s Services (ACS) that reports directly to the mayor. The move fundamentally reversed the city’s basic child-welfare philosophy, prioritizing criminal justice and the protection of children rather than holding families together.
In 1997 President Clinton signed the Adoption and Safe Families Act (ASFA), mandating the creation, within one year, of a permanency plan for each child who enters state foster care and requires states to initiate steps terminating parental rights for any child removed from his/her home for 15 of the last 22 months – thereby making the child eligible for adoption and able to leave the system. Like Giuliani’s plan, the act attempted to address the problem of children languishing for years in “temporary” foster care, bouncing around from placement to placement with no permanent home. Incentive payments for increasing the number of adoptions and new funding with broad discretion for states to promote adoptions were also part of the act. Adoptions increased 57% nationwide by the year 2000 (though many states had instituted their own reforms to expedite permanent placement before the federal statute so it is difficult to isolate the act’s impact). In New York, by the year 2000, the Giuliani Administration had cut the foster care population to fewer than 17,000, with nearly 35,000 children staying in their homes and receiving counseling and other preventive services – and, in a step towards accountability, all foster care agencies were required to receive annual performance evaluations from the city.

Current State of Foster Care
Children, almost invariably, arrive in foster care afraid, angry and confused in the wake of a traumatic family crisis that brings dramatic changes and fractures their lives. According to the latest national statistics, just over 800,000 children, including 40,000 infants, pass through the system every year, with more than 500,000 taken into foster care. 40% of foster children are white, 34% are black and 18% are Hispanic. Their stay lasts an average of 31 months (the median stay in NYC is 58 months, among the longest in the nation) and includes an average of three to four different foster care homes or institutions before being reunited with their family or being adopted. In New York, one-third stay in the system for more than three years and 17 percent remain in foster care for five years or more – some having lived in more than 20 different foster homes/institutions and others (about 9% of the foster care population) live in group care institutions for intensive services/treatment, frequently because they are considered to poorly behaved or too mentally ill for a home to handle. Large numbers of children in group homes is considered undesirable, both because group care is expensive (roughly four times the cost of regular foster care) and because children are believed to be best served in families - where one loving and stable adult in a child’s life can make all the difference - not by rotating staffs in group homes.
Adoption is often a consideration for foster parents. In fact, about two-thirds of the children placed in foster care are later adopted into one of their foster home placements. Facilitating and expediting adoptions, especially for those children with special needs, has become a primary focus for lawmakers. The federal government now funds 50% to 80% of foster care maintenance and adoption assistance payment (usually ‘adoption subsidies’) and states receive federal reimbursements for 50% of eligible administrative costs and 75% of eligible training costs. There are currently more than 126,000 foster children across the country available for adoption. Some children, particularly those over 10 years old - who comprise half of the foster care population - have little chance of being adopted and 20,000 each year “age out” of the system by turning 18, never having been adopted. Despite more than a decade of intended reform, the nation's foster care system is still overcrowded - many social workers have 3 to 4 times the recommended caseload of 17, leading to “burnout” and the 20% turnover of child welfare workers. But taxpayers are spending $22 billion a year, or $40,000 a child, on foster care programs. In America, child welfare is basically a state-funded program assisted by $5 billion in federal money divvied up among the states, with 65% going to foster care homes and institutions, 22% to adoption, 11% to in-home and preventive services, with the remainder coming from city governments.

Education

We shouldn’t be surprised to find that foster children struggle in school. Foster children exhibit high rates of grade retention, lower scores on standardized tests, and higher absenteeism, tardiness, truancy and dropout rates. Life in the foster care system is often unstable. Such changes exact an emotional toll and cause disruptions in schooling. A Columbia University survey of adults formerly in foster care found they “strongly believed they had been shifted around too much while in care, and as a result, they suffered, especially in terms of education.” Foster child voucher or scholarship programs (recently signed into law in Arizona) are a potential solution that would give children the ability to choose and stay in a high-quality school even when they change homes (homes near the school could be given priority). Staying in the same high-quality school year after year would allow children, without strong family ties, to build long-term friendships, peer groups and a sense of belonging.

Substance Abuse and Child Abuse

Experts estimate that 80 to 90 percent of foster care placements can be traced to substance abuse with children suffering the collateral damage of their parent’s addiction – often escaping alarming living conditions to enter foster care. An epidemic of methamphetamine use released a record-breaking flood of children, over 304,000 nationwide, into the foster system in 2004. All too frequently coupled with substance abuse problems - if there are children in the household - are child abuse problems. Each week, nearly 60,000 children in the United States are reported as abused or neglected, with nearly 900,000 confirmed abuse victims in 2004. About half of those children end up in foster care each year — double the number of 25 years ago.
Children with histories of chronic maltreatment, such as physical and psychological neglect or abandonment, physical abuse, or sexual abuse inflicted by a primary caregiver (or other member of the household) are at risk of developing severe psychiatric problems. A study by the National Adoption Center found that 52% of adoptable children exhibit “reactive attachment disorder” (RAD) symptoms - typically before five years of age (the disorder can reportedly be diagnosed as early as the first month of life). The trauma these children experience disrupts the normal development of secure attachment, making the formation of healthy relationships, with caregivers, peers or family, difficult. Related developmental problems include; depression, high-anxiety, “acting-out,” and dissociative symptoms. These children require specialized treatment (e.g. psychotherapy) that addresses the underlying causative trauma and which seeks to build healthy and secure relationships with permanent caregivers.

New York State
The New York Office of Children and Family Services (OCFS) was created to improve the integration of services for New York's children, youth, families and vulnerable populations and to promote their development and protect them from violence, neglect, abuse and abandonment. The agency offers support and emphasizes teamwork, full disclosure and dissemination of background information of children and open communication and regular meetings between foster parents, caseworkers and biological parents. OCFS trains and supports foster families committed to living and working with children dealing with issues of abuse and/or neglect and the resultant behavioral, psychological, and/or physical problems.
OCFS has numerous responsibilities including: foster care, adoption and adoption assistance, child protective services, preventive services for children and families, services for pregnant adolescents, child care and referral programs, and protective programs for vulnerable adults. The agency operates 30 juvenile residential facilities, six community-based group homes, eight day-placement centers, and two reception center programs for juvenile delinquents and juvenile offenders placed in the custody of OCFS by family and criminal courts. OCFS works closely with municipalities such as the local social services districts and county youth bureaus to ensure that adequate youth development services and programs are available at the local level. The number of children in foster care in New York State has decreased from 53,902 children in 1995 to 26,602 in 2005, a significant reversal of trends in the 1980s and early 1990s.

Aging Out of the Foster Care System
The key to foster care is to prepare children to live as adults once they leave the system. Former foster children, however, face many obstacles and are heightened risk of poor life outcomes. When foster kids turn 18 they do get some help – Congress provides $140 million annually in state grants to provide housing subsidies, medical benefits and education or training vouchers - but much of the state support system comes to an end. For many, the challenge of independence is overwhelming - experts estimate that 30% of the homeless in America and some 25% of those in prison were once in foster care and they are highly susceptible to drug and alcohol abuse and poor physical and mental health and many become dependent on state services.
Programs to facilitate the transition to self-sufficiency through assistance in obtaining a high school diploma, career or post-secondary education exploration, vocational training, job placement and retention, training in daily living skills, training in budgeting and financial management skills, substance abuse prevention, and preventive health activities (including smoking avoidance, nutrition education, and pregnancy prevention) are all critical for this population.

The City’s New Plan
In 2006 the Bloomberg Administration initiated child welfare reform by hiring hundreds of caseworkers to investigate abuse and neglect allegations. On March 21, 2007, Bloomberg shifted the focus to those children who have already been taken out of their homes and announced an ambitious plan to move children through foster care more swiftly, with fewer moves within the system and more limited use of institutional care. Echoing Giuliani’s short-lived 1993 plan, the Bloomberg plan gives agencies financial incentives to move children into homes more quickly by changing the funding structure for the city’s $466 million in foster care money - eliminating the payments agencies receive for each day a child spends in care in favor of a lump sum based on the number of children served annually (based on fiscal 2007 numbers). The foster care agencies in the city would also be given broad discretion in the types of care they provide with city money, which city officials believe will allow them the flexibility to offer more support services for children in their own homes.
The proposed overhaul would eliminate, to Union uproar, the jobs of 650 case managers who currently do paper reviews of cases and make decisions about the child’s future placement. The plan will, however, create 500 higher-paying agency-oversight positions with responsibility for everything from updating monthly scorecards detailing agency performance to meeting with agency caseworkers and biological and/or foster families to make decisions on individual cases. The change aims to facilitate city-agency cooperation, as the 500 supervisors are to be working hand-in-hand and face-to-face – rather than passing paperwork - with agency caseworkers and biological and/or foster families to develop plans for each of the city’s 17,000 children in foster care as well as the 27,000 children receiving preventive services in their homes.
ACS Commissioner John Mattingly hailed the plan as a long overdue elimination of an impersonal, slow, bureaucratic system for a new “more flexible, creative on the ground kind of system.” The city would also increase funding for agencies that reduce the number of children in group care, an expected 15% - 20% budgetary windfall for most agencies. The city hopes agencies will use this money to develop services that will help children stay in their own homes, or in foster homes rather than in group facilities. For example, agencies might develop mobile mental health teams that could be on call and dispatched at any hour to help when a child rages out of control.
James Purcell, executive director of the Council of Family and Child Caring Agencies, the umbrella and advocacy group for nearly all of the city’s private foster care agencies, questions whether the plan provides enough money for in-home prevention programs to meet the city’s optimistic targets for cutting the foster care population. Furthermore, Purcell believes that there, simply, may not be enough families willing to take all the troubled children in the city.

Conclusion
Every child has the need for permanency, security, stability and continuity within their living environment and their relationships, and, children in the foster care system are, all too frequently, caught in limbo in the child welfare system. Foster children have critical needs that foster parents provide. These needs are not just food and shelter, but include support, encouragement, reassurance, self-esteem, self-worth, and most importantly, love.
As the public policy pendulum swings back and forth between family preservation and protecting children by placing them in foster care - most experts now agree that the best thing to do is try to leave them at home, if at all possible, and provide good services to help the family cope. If that's not possible, the next best solution is to have family members or nearby foster parents take the kids in, and at the same time provide a group of professionals (a therapist, a pediatrician, a social worker, a tutor) to help the kids and the adults. This is sometimes called "wraparound services" and has been working well in pilot programs in this country and in others, like England. A few obvious solutions: lighten social workers' case loads to the recommended number; compensate foster parents more fairly and in return demand they keep children, even when they act out; offer services to children aging out of the system; help teach young parents skills they need to care for their children; place foster children near their parents, or with extended family whenever possible; smooth the way for loving foster parents to adopt and make foster care a national priority.
The Child Welfare policy players and the power they wield are not pitted against one another ideologically in the same way as they are on more contentious issues because nobody is against helping children. It is merely a question of how much. Upwelling of public outrage, like that created by the death of 6 year old Elisa in 1995, may be the necessary impetus to make child welfare a funding priority over higher profile issues with more organized, vocal and influential constituencies. There is evidence to suggest that foster care is a generational cycle. Young women in foster care are more likely to have early pregnancies and place their own children in the foster system. No matter what your political stripes, it is plain to see that these children will be costing us billions of dollars more down the line if we fail them when they are young. Investing in our children is the ultimate investment and funding child welfare and improving its effectiveness should be an obvious priority, but it only becomes one when tragedy puts it on the front page, unfortunately there are a thousand quiet tragedies a day that do not even make the papers.

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China