Kosovo: At the Fringe of Empires
Serbs protest Kosovo IndependenceOn Sunday February 17, 2008 the desperately poor, predominantly Muslim and ethnic Albanian province of Kosovo declared independence from Serbia in a bid to become Europe’s newest country. The declaration, 17 years after the dissolution of the former Yugoslavia began, thrust the small, landlocked, overpopulated territory of 2 million people into the center of an acrimonious confrontation between the West – recognizing Kosovo independence and backing the principle of self-determination – and the Serbian government and its allies in the Kremlin who reject Kosovo’s declaration and champion the principle of sovereignty. Though the formation of the Republic of Kosovo stems most directly from the fallout of the Kosovo War (1996-1999) and the subsequent nearly 9 years of limbo under UN interim administration the roots of conflict are deep and date back centuries with the most recent episode tied to the rise of Serbian and Albanian nationalism in the Balkans under the Ottoman Empire in the 19th century. This retrospective take on Kosovo attempts to illuminate and synthesize the nature of the conflict and thereby enable decision makers to better gauge the viability and wisdom of the options for the future.
Early History
The claimants to disputed territory, anywhere in the world, frequently argue their case on historical grounds. However, there is seldom agreement on how far back in time to go and ancient history invariably blends with mythology – as Goethe said, “patriotism ruins history.” Problematic though the task may be, attempting to understand any territorial dispute begins with a look at the competing claims on history. Kosovo’s recorded past began with the Roman conquest around 160 BC. Roman rule continued, with Slavic migrations reaching the Balkans in the 6th and 7th centuries, until the area was absorbed into the predominately Christian Byzantine (or “Eastern Roman Empire”) Empire in the 850s. Migration had made Kosovo majority Slavic by the 9th century and the region (larger than present-day Kosovo) gradually rose to prominence as the center of Slavic resistance to Constantinople, alternatively falling under Byzantine and Serbian or Bulgarian control, before being definitively absorbed into the Serbian Kingdom in the 12th century. According to Serbian history, Kosovo then became not only the center of the secular Serbian medieval state but also was home to the Serbian Orthodox Church, the spiritual center of the Serbian Empire, which was formed later at the peak of Serbian power in 1346. In 1389, the Turks crushed the Serbs in the pivotal Battle of Kosovo and by 1455, the Ottoman Empire had fully conquered Kosovo – and four years later – the whole of Northern Serbian territory as well. The Serbs saw Kosovo, the cradle of their once-proud Serbian empire and their “spiritual Jerusalem,” overrun by Muslim invaders and were then ground under the heel of the Ottomans for nearly four centuries. The idea of the lost Battle of Kosovo – and the sense of historical grievance that came with it – has since been elevated to mythic status, intimately intertwined with Serbia’s national identity and today remains the defining moment in Serbian history.
Ottoman Serbia
As Serbian nationalist history reads, under Ottoman rule, many recalcitrant Serbs fought first with Hungary and later with the Austrians in multiple wars against their common enemy; the Ottoman Turks. However, whenever peace returned, the rebellious Serbs repeatedly fell mercy to Turkish vengeance – they paid a martyr’s price for resistance. Besieged by hostilities and deteriorating treatment, Orthodox Christian Serbs (who had valiantly maintained Serbian culture in the face of oppression) began to abandon Kosovo in the 16th and 17th centuries. Along with the Battle of Kosovo, another injustice emblazoned on the Serbian psyche was the “Great Migration” – the Serbian peoples’ forced exodus from Kosovo. After falling briefly under Austrian control in the Great War (1683-1699), a Serbian patriarch, fearing Ottoman retaliation for the Serbian role in the war, led 37,000 families out of Kosovo north to Hungary with the retreating Habsburgs. Other migrations left throughout the 18th century, though Kosovo still remained majority Serbian, to autonomous Serb-controlled Belgrade. The cycle of hostility continued in 1766 when the Ottoman rulers abolished the Serbian Orthodox patriarchate of Péc and imposed a tax on all non-Muslims.
1815, however, Serbian uprisings were able to secure limited autonomy from the Ottoman Empire. By 1871, with the Ottoman Empire showing signs of decline, an emboldened Serbia began to cogitate on retaking Kosovo and the rest of “Old Serbia.” Serbs, for their part, had also been expelling Albanians from Southern Serbia and by the end of the 19th century Albanian migration to Kosovo (allegedly engineered by the Ottomans to displace Serbs), together with the outward flows of Serbians had changed the face of Kosovo – Albanians had become the absolute majority. Albanians quickly grew leery of the mounting Serbian threat and fear that the lands they inhabited would be partitioned among Montenegro, Serbia, Bulgaria, and Greece fueled a rise or ‘awakening’ of Albanian nationalism. The Russo-Turkish War (1877-1878) exposed Ottoman weakness like never before. In 1878, still reeling, the Ottomans agreed to a peace accord at the Congress of Berlin, with the cities of Pristina and Kosovska Mitrovica under Serbian control (and outside of Ottoman jurisdiction), while the rest of Kosovo remained under Ottoman control. After centuries of oppression the newly empowered Serbian police and troops were eager to return the favor to Albanians, whom they had viewed as in league with the Ottomans. Serbs harsh treatment of Albanians prompted the formation of the League of Prizren in 1878 – a symbolic rejection of the Congress of Berlin and defiance of Serbian rule – with romantic appeals to the glory of ancient Illyria in Roman times, the League aimed to unify the 4 Albanian-inhabited Vilayets (Turkish administrative divisions) into one Albanian autonomous region. Besides their political supremacy, Serbs, still comprised 40% of the population of Kosovo and, along with other Slavs and Turks, were able to successfully oppose the unification. The foregoing demographic shift to majority Albanian Muslim and the jurisdictional division of Kosovo – coupled with centuries of enmity and inter-ethnic strife – only intensified Albanian and Serbian nationalism in Kosovo at the beginning of the 20th century.
The Ottoman Collapse and the Resulting Power Vacuum
As Ottoman power dwindled other powers took notice and the “Eastern Question,” regarding the integrity of the Ottoman Empire, loomed large. Russia wanted access to the Mediterranean and thus pursued a Pan-Slavic foreign policy, supporting Bulgaria and Serbia. Britain wanted to deny Russia that access and accordingly supported the integrity of the Ottoman Empire, but as the Empire slipped further, the British supported Greece as another potential bulwark against Russian expansion. Austria-Hungary grew anxious that the chaos loosed by an Ottoman collapse would threaten its ruling elite and embolden Serbia, including Austria-Hungary’s own large Serbian and Croatian populations. Serbia, after centuries of subjugation, grew eager to seek vengeance of its own on the Ottomans. Kosovo found itself cast in the role of a prized pawn at the symbolic crossroads of a struggle, suffused with history, between larger powers.
The Balkan Wars and World War I
Low intensity warfare broke out in 1904 in Macedonia between Greek and Bulgarian groups and the Ottoman army. The year 1908 brought the “Young Turk” revolution, in which troubled European provinces, disgruntled at the harried state of the empire and blaming the Sultan, restored parliament (previously suspended by the Sultan in 1878) and temporarily raised hopes of a representative multi-ethnic parliament, hopes that were dashed when more hard-line nationalist elements wrested control of the movement. With the turmoil in the Ottoman Empire, Austria-Hungary smelled blood and seized the opportunity to annex the Ottoman province of Bosnia-Herzegovina (despite its 1 million Orthodox Serbs). Following suit, first Bulgaria and then Montenegro declared themselves fully independent kingdoms. The Serbian government, looking to capitalize as well, looked to its formerly Serb territories in the south, including Kosovo.
Albanian Kosovars as well sought independence and in 1910 an uprising spread through Kosovo. The powerful Young Turk movement, however, supported central rule and opposed any sort of autonomy desired by the Kosovars, particularly the Albanians and the rebellion was quashed by the time of the Sultan’s visit in 1911. The power shift brought by the Ottoman decline and the resultant newly emboldened Balkan nations eventually triggered the Balkan Wars of 1912-1913. By the end of 1912, most of Kosovo had been taken by Serbia and the Balkan League (including Bulgaria, Montenegro and Greece), while the western Kosovo region of Metohija was taken by the kingdom of Montenegro. Now it was the local Albanian population that flooded out as Serbs planned a recolonization of Kosovo, with Serb families moving in to equalize the demographic balance between Albanians and Serbs. Today, Albanians still harbor memories (or at least were taught to ‘remember’) of harsh Serbian treatment during the recolonization, which feeds simmering resentment. World War I erupted in 1914 and in 1916, in what came to be known as The Great Serbian Retreat, the Serbian army abandoned Kosovo but pushed back into control by 1918 to form the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes at the close of World War I.
The Interwar Period
From 1918 to 1929 the Serbian population surged as Kosovo was split into 4 counties, 3 Serbian and one under Montenegro. In 1929 the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes officially became known as the Kingdom of Yugoslavia and Kosovo was split yet again into three Yugoslav divisions. The onset of World War II and the Axis invasion of 1941 brought the end of the Kingdom of Yugoslavia. The largest part of Kosovo became a part of Italian-controlled Albania, other areas were controlled by the Tsardom of Bulgaria and occupied by the Nazis.
Post World War II Yugoslav Kosovo
Though conceived in 1943, in 1948, Josep Broz Tito officially established the socialist Federal People’s Republic of Yugoslavia. Kosovo was liberated in 1944 and became the “Autonomous Kosovo-Metohijan Province,” which together with Vojvodina Province comprised the People’s Republic of Serbia within greater Yugoslavia . Though officially “autonomous” (in an effort to protect its Albanian majority) Albanians claimed there never was any real autonomy. Tito and Soviet leader Joseph Stalin had both opposed the Nazis and emerged from World War II as staunch allies. Tito’s forces famously shot down two American airplanes flying over Yugoslav airspace in 1946, the first aerial shootdowns of Western aircraft of the Cold War, fueling deep distrust of Yugoslavia in the United States. Despite early cooperation, Stalin envisioned Soviet domination of the whole of Eastern Europe while Tito was considered the natural leader of Yugoslavia as a celebrated war hero and was thus unwilling to relinquish command. Tito also disagreed with many of Stalin’s methods of governance and refused to link the Soviet and Yugoslav economies. Relations broke down entirely when Yugoslavia discovered Soviet spies had made a propaganda film about the Yugoslav resistance to Sovietization that downplayed Tito’s role in the war. This infuriated Tito and became a full-blown crisis when Stalin demanded that Tito join a federation with the Soviet satellite Bulgaria. Tito refused and Stalin responded by throwing Tito and the Yugoslav communists out of the Communist Information Bureau (Cominform), ending all Soviet-Yugoslav ties.
Albanian history alleges that Tito’s interior minister Aleksandar Rankovic brutally repressed Albanians from 1945 until 1966, including bouts of ethnic cleansing and attempts to force Albanian emigration out of Kosovo to Turkey. After Rankovic, Kosovo attained internal autonomy and with the constitution of 1974 the Kosovar government acquired greater powers including a President, Prime Minister and a seat in the Federal Presidency – becoming autonomous within the Socialist Republic of Serbia which was itself a member of the Yugoslav Federation.
Post 1945
From 1945 forward and intensifying after 1974, yet another transformative influx of migration tripled the total number of Albanians, tipping Kosovo’s ethnic balance to 90% Albanian. The overall number of Serbs barely increased after the war, dropping from 15% to 8% of the growing total population. With the death of Josep Tito in 1980, Yugoslavia lost its founding father as well as much of its stability. Beginning in March 1981, Kosovar Albanian students organized protests seeking republic-status for Kosovo within Yugoslavia. Serbia responded by clamping down harder on its poorest most troublesome province. Throughout the 1980s, inter-ethnic tensions continued to worsen as Serbian groups also organized protests seeking protection from discrimination and violence, protests that were heavy-handedly put down by Yugoslav state authorities resulting in increased bitterness and increased emigration of Kosovar Serbs and other ethnic groups.
The Rise of Milosevic
With the fate of Yugoslavia hanging precariously in the balance, Slobodan Milosevic began his rise to power in Serbia, Yugoslavia’s largest republic, by casting himself as the champion of the Serbian nation, averring, “the oppression of Serbs has ended.” In 1986, the Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts released the “SANU Memorandum” warning that Yugoslavia was suffering from ethnic strife and announced that the disintegration of the Yugoslav economy into separate economic sectors was putting the Federation in jeopardy. With particular attention to Kosovo, the memorandum concluded that the Kosovar Serbs were being subjected to "physical, political, legal and cultural genocide" in an "open and total war" that had been ongoing since the spring of 1981. Milosevic’s rise to power was fueled by his exploitation of the Serbian sense of historical grievance, from Ottoman rule to the 1986 status of Kosovo (outside of Serbian control) discussed in the memorandum. The Memorandum's authors claimed that 200,000 Serbs had moved out of the province over the previous twenty years and warned that there would soon be none left "unless things change radically." Though Milosevic and most communists publicly denounced the memorandum, in March of 1989 in the wake of violent demonstrations, Milosevic imposed a curfew in Kosovo and dramatically curtailed Kosovo autonomy, claiming that the constitutional changes were necessary to protect Kosovo's remaining Serbs against harassment from the Albanian majority. To further stoke nationalistic fervor, Milosevic chose to deliver perhaps his most famous speech in June, 1989 at Kosovo Field to over 1 million Serbs on the 600 year anniversary of the Battle of Kosovo in order to highlight the restored dignity of the newly unified Serbian people.
In the speech Milosevic vowed to put an end to the disunity and treason of Serbian politicians that led to tragedy and Serbian agony (the foregoing separation of Serbia from Kosovo, its cultural and spiritual Jerusalem) that morally “exceeded fascist aggression.” Though the speech has been distilled in the Western popular memory as a war-mongering diatribe, the speech itself championed a harmonious, multi-ethnic Serbia with prosperity “irrespective of national or religious affiliation.” Though perhaps this was just lip-service to morality, it laid the groundwork in the Serbian imagination for a just national cause worth fighting for. A cause Milosevic infused with history, Old Testament undertones and the Serbian Millenarian Orthodox idea that, “those who remain faithful under duress will be redeemed,” a reference to the Serb King Lazar who died while fighting Sultan Murad in the 1389 Battle of Kosovo . Historical reference to the Ottoman Empire, as a tool of political ideology, has also been employed repeatedly by Albanian Nationalists who link their goals to “national” versions of Ottoman history. In these depictions, Kosovo is portrayed as an enduring corporate entity (despite massive migrations and demographic shifts) that suffered centuries of oppression under “Turkish” imperial rule. Like in Serbia, politicians have successfully nurtured resentment, mobilized extremists and silenced debate by championing an anti-Ottoman form of nationalism.
Serbian Rule and the Kosovo War
Kosovo remained under direct Serbian rule from 1990 to 1996 and Milosevic grew more assertive by replacing locally chosen leaders with his sympathizers and eventually formally disbanding Kosovo’s assembly and government. As a result of Milosevic’s measures more than 80,000 Kosovo Albanians were expelled from their state jobs in Kosovo. Unemployment soon skyrocketed to 80%, inflation was estimated at 10,000% and an estimated one third of the male population went abroad (primarily Germany and Switzerland) to find work. Albanian cultural autonomy was also attacked, the only Albanian-language newspaper, Rilindja, was banned as were TV and radio broadcasts in Albanian, 800 lecturers from Pristina University were fired and 22,500 out of 23,000 students were expelled. All of this was implemented by some 40,000 Yugoslav troops that replaced the Albanian-run security forces with a virtual police state.
The Democratic League of Kosovo, led by the Albanian writer Ibrahim Rugova, responded with a non-violent separatist movement, a precursor to the ethnic Albanian guerilla group known as the Kosovo Liberation Army (KLA). Rugova called on the Albanian populace to boycott the Yugoslav and Serbian states by not participating in elections, by ignoring the military draft (compulsory in Yugoslavia) and most importantly by not paying any taxes or duties to the State. He also called for the creation of parallel Albanian schools, clinics and hospitals. In September 1991, despite widespread harassment and violence by Serbian security forces, a referendum on Kosovo independence reported 90% turnout among the province's Albanians —nearly a million votes in all—which approved the creation of an independent "Republic of Kosovo.” The Serbian government declared the referendum illegal and the results null and void.
Rugova's policy of passive resistance succeeded in keeping Kosovo quiet but this came at the cost of increasing frustration among the Albanian population of Kosovo. Continuing Serbian repression had radicalized many Albanians, some of whom decided that only armed resistance would effect real change. In April of 1996, four attacks on Serbian security personnel were carried out by a hitherto unknown organization calling itself the "Kosovo Liberation Army" (KLA). The KLA at this stage consisted mainly of local farmers and displaced and unemployed workers, though it is widely believed that the KLA received financial and material support from the Kosovo Albanian diaspora in Europe and elsewhere. Most Albanians saw the KLA as legitimate "freedom fighters" whilst the Yugoslav government labelled them as "terrorists" attacking police and civilians. KLA attacks soon intensified and Serbian police responded and began to pursue the KLA, resulting in the deaths of 30 civilians and 4 Serb policemen. Another high profile incident involved the killing of 60 Albanians, including 18 women and ten children. Such violence drew strong Western condemnation. The KLA proved to be a formidable foe, despite the overwhelming Serbian firepower, the KLA consolidated their control in multiple strongholds across Kosovo. In May 1998, the Yugoslav army and the Serb Ministry of the Interior police began an operation to clear the border of the KLA. This lasted several days and reports of summary executions and killings of civilians reached the media which led to threats of bombing by Western powers. NATO responded to this offensive with Operation Determined Falcon, an air show over the Yugoslav borders.
During this time Milosevic reached an agreement with Boris Yeltsin (who had previously shunned Serbian leadership to deal only with Yugoslav leadership) to stop offensive operations. Through June and into mid-July the KLA continued its offensive. On the 17th of July 1998 in the two close by villages to Orahovac, Retimlije and Opteruša, all the Serb males were kidnapped and later found dead. This led to a series of retaliatory Serb and Yugoslav offensives which would continue into the beginning of August. An estimated 300,000 Albanian refugees were displaced by the fighting, many of them without adequate food and shelter, with winter approaching – precipitating a humanitarian crisis.
By 1998 Western interest and outrage had increased. Officially, the international community demanded an end to Serbian offensives against the KLA, (without mention of an end to KLA-perpetrated attacks), while attempting to convince the KLA to drop its bid for independence. Under Western pressure, a ceasefire was brokered in October of 1998 which featured a large contingent of OSCE peace monitors. However, the ceasefire broke down within a matter of weeks and fighting resumed in December 1998. The January to March 1999 phase of the war brought increasing insecurity in urban areas, including bombings and murders.
KLA attacks and Serbian reprisals continued throughout the winter of 1998–1999, culminating on January 15, 1999 with the Racak massacre . Rolling TV cameras featured United States Ambassador William Walker walking through mutilated bodies of Albanians. Shortly after that he held a press conference where he stated that he had just witnessed Serbian crimes against civilians. The massacre was the turning point of the war. NATO decided that the conflict could only be settled by introducing a military peacekeeping force under the auspices of NATO, to forcibly restrain the two sides.
In the end, on March 18, 1999, the Albanian, American and British delegation signed what became known as the Rambouillet Accords while the Serbian and Russian delegations refused. The accords called for NATO administration of Kosovo as an autonomous province within Yugoslavia with a force of 30,000 NATO troops to maintain order in Kosovo. NATO's bombing campaign lasted from March 24 to June 11, 1999, and involved all of the NATO members to some degree—even Greece, despite publicly opposing the war.
NATO had seriously underestimated Milošević's will to resist: few in Brussels thought that the campaign would last more than a few days, and thus the initial bombardment was nowhere near the concentrated bombardments seen in Baghdad in 1991. On the ground, the ethnic cleansing campaign by the Serbians was stepped up and within a week of the war starting, over 300,000 Kosovo Albanians had fled into neighboring Albania and Macedonia, with many thousands more displaced within Kosovo. By April, the United Nations was reporting that 850,000 people—the vast majority of them Albanians—had fled their homes.
After the war ended, the UN Security Council passed Resolution 1244 that gave Kosovo autonomy within the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia to be carried out under transitional UN administration (UNMIK) and authorized KFOR, a NATO-led peacekeeping force. Altogether, more than 11,000 deaths have been recorded, with over 3,000 still classified as missing. Some 200,000-280,000, representing the majority of the Serb population, left when the Serbian forces left. There was also some looting of Serb properties and even violence against some of those Serbs and Roma who remained. Today, roughly 120,000 Serbs remain in Kosovo, but are subject to ongoing harassment and discrimination, according to Amnesty International. In March 2004, Kosovo experienced its worst inter-ethnic violence since the Kosovo War. The unrest in 2004 was sparked by a series of minor events that soon cascaded into large-scale riots. The UN-backed talks, led by UN Special Envoy Martti Ahtisaari, began in February 2006 to determine the final status of Kosovo. While progress was made on technical matters, both parties remained diametrically opposed on the question of status itself
In February 2007, Ahtisaari delivered a draft status settlement proposal to leaders in Belgrade and Pristina, the basis for a draft UN Security Council Resolution which proposed ‘supervised independence' for the province. A draft resolution, backed by the United States, the United Kingdom and other European members of the Security Council, was presented and rewritten four times to try to accommodate Russian concerns that such a resolution would undermine the principle of state sovereignty. Russia, which holds a veto in the Security Council, had stated that it would not support any resolution which was not acceptable to both Belgrade and Kosovo Albanians.
The Kosovar Assembly approved a declaration of independence on 17 February 2008. Over the following days, several countries (the United States, Turkey, Albania, Austria, Germany, Italy, France, the United Kingdom, Republic of China (Taiwan), Australia and others) announced their recognition, despite protests by Serbia in the UN Security Council. As of April 2008, the UN Security Council remains divided with the USA, UK, and France recognizing the declaration of independence, and Russia and the People's Republic of China considering it illegal. Serbia has offered wide autonomy but Kosovo’s ethnic Albanian leaders insist on independence.
As was commonly said in Yugoslavia after 1989, with layered meaning, “Everything started with Kosovo.” Kosovo’s superlatively tumultuous past, marked by subjugation, persecution transformative migration, division and violent change of rule, provides the backdrop. It is precisely the interethnic Serbian-Albanian hostilities based on competing senses of historical grievance that make this conflict so deeply historical – and so intractable. "It is as if the blood spilled during the centuries is leaching back up through the soil and into men's minds." It is a conflict with a bewildering array of factors. Unfortunately, it is a question of honor and any solution would require one side or both to let bygones be bygones and focus on the present more than the past. Political realities as they are, no Kosovar nor Serbian leader can back down. For now, peace must reign and with established peace more options become viable.
Comments