Ghosts of Japanese and US Subjugation in Korean Mad Cow Protesters Wounded Pride


The roar of tens of thousands of chanting South Koreans grew deafening Tuesday night in central Seoul catapulting the former Hyundai chairman and mayor of Seoul, President Lee Myung Bak, into a full-fledged political crisis and left many Americans bewildered and scratching our heads. The candle-lit protests began in defiance of an April US-ROK deal that lifted a 5-year ban on US beef that was sparked by fears of Mad Cow Disease in US cattle in 2003. Despite the World Organization for Animal Health's announcements that US beef is now safe and the fact that Americans eat vast quantities of beef aged over 30 months at the time of slaughter (18% of the US market), Koreans still feel they are being disrespected and caving in to US pressure by allowing US beef from cattle over 30 months old at the time of slaughter.
The Korean Psyche
Since 1905, Korean pride has been ground under the heels of Japan and the US. Impetuous, indignant, and emboldened by prosperity, many Koreans now tirelessly bash their leader for any perceived capitulation to outsiders - to the point of being self-defeating to their nation. President Lee Myung Bak, overly eager to patch up relations with the US, disastrously forgot Korean history and ignored the opponents of the deal. Misinformation on the streets abounds and the protesters really aren't interested in logical, rational arguments, their cry of protest is guttural and emotional.
The current deal is a slap in the face because Japan got what Korea couldn’t – a block on beef 30 months or older - so the ghosts of Japanese and US domination have been summoned in tandem. Rash as the protesters may be, they will not be ignored and right or wrong, Lee must swallow his pride and bend or the protesters will break him. To be fair, not all Koreans think alike and a rival protest, supporting the beef deal, was also held, though it was dwarfed by the opposing rally.
Calling the protesters rash is not to say there is no reason to be skeptical about American beef, those reasons are just not what is motivating the vast majority of protesters.
For several days of the protest the principal demand was a ban on beef from cattle over 30 months, after Bush agreed over the phone to the ban the opposition called the phone call a "political stunt." Another demand was "renegotiation" of the beef deal, however, after the announcement of the Korean Trade Minister's trip to the US to reopen negotiations, the opposition coalition declared, "Holding additional negotiations is just another way of deceiving the people." Furthermore, in advance of the negotiations, coalition official Pak Won Suk stressed the absence of a reliable method of checking whether imported beef is really from cattle younger than 30 months at the time of slaughter. The coalition is worse than disingenuous, it is preemptively attacking any hope of resolution. Others have spurred online rumors that cow tissue is present in cosmetics, diapers, toilet paper and noodles. Couple that with alarmist TV programs that had scientists claiming that Koreans are particularly genetically vulnerable to human Mad Cow (later refuted by other Korean scientists) and you have a perfect storm. The opposition is only interested in bringing down Lee Myung Bak and his pro-business, pro-US, arrogant, "bulldozer" style administration. Beef is the catalyst, but the issues with Lee Myung Bak, including the economic crunch of rising food and oil prices and Korean public's demands for an immediate economic upturn they have not seen in Lee's 4 months in office, but more than anything it is about wounded pride, and simmering economic tension and the Korean penchant for, at times festive, protest. To make matters worse, yesterday, 5,000 Korean truckers went on strike demanding guaranteed haulage payments on the face of rising fuel costs.
Reasons to be skeptical about US beef?
The most extensive US testing in 2005 and 2006 tested only a fraction, roughly 650,000, of the 30 million animals slaughtered and found only 3 cases. This sounds troubling at first glance but the science is a little stickier. In a sample of 650,000, 3 cases could have developed spontaneously. Only a much higher number would indicate unsafe practices and underlying problems in US cattle populations. Regardless, some European countries, where feeding ruminant protein to other ruminants was a much more common practice (the believed cause of Mad Cow disease), test upwards of 10 million animals a year and the Japanese test every single one of the 1.2 million they slaughter. US Department of Agriculture officials explained that their testing was only for surveillance, not food safety. The sampling was designed to give 95 percent certainty of finding the disease if it existed in one in a million cattle which is the rate that would be expected from spontaneous genetic mutations (but is virtually non-occurring in animals under 36 months), such as those found in humans with the degenerative brain disease known as Creutzfeld-Jakob syndrome.
The Agriculture Dept. Chief Veterinarian ridiculed the Japanese 100% testing likening it to mandating testing of every man, woman and child for prostate cancer. But for some, including many Koreans, if there is a one in a million chance of getting human Mad Cow, that is just a risk they are unwilling to take. Few things are more personal than what we put into our bodies and the bodies of our children. Other critics of the US beef industry cite the fact the the FDA does not certify beef safety but rather the Dept. of Agriculture itself which exists to increase farmer and rancher profits (testing in many European nations is carried out by a separate agency not the Dept. of Agriculture). Also proposed FDA bans on feeding farm animals cow blood, chicken dung and plate waste were never implemented. Furthermore some US farmers, including Creekstone Farms, hurt by the Japanese, Korean and other blocks on US beef have volunteered to test all their animals themselves. The Agriculture department denied permission, saying such testing would “imply a consumer safety aspect that is not scientifically warranted.” American consumer groups were apoplectic, but the beef industry which did not want to be pressured to spend $25 or so testing every animal applauded the move. Creekstone is still suing the Agriculture Department for the right to test.
The point is that, once one farm starts to test then every other feels pressured to do so as well, even though the chances of eating infected meat under the current system are close to the chances of being struck by lightning.
In July of 2007, when Korean retailer Lotte started selling US beef after a 3 year ban, opposing civics groups threw cow manure at the deli inside a store in protest.

Protectionists in nations with a proclivity for protectionism have seized on Mad Cow as an incredibly potent fear-mongering tool (the always fatal human version of Mad Cow slowly eats your brain and makes you insane), because there is always a chance of infection without 100% testing. The Dept. of Agriculture, however, feels that because feeding ruminants ruminants was never common in the US and has been banned since 1997, and because in all mathematical likelihood, there is far below a one in a million chance that any animal is infected and also because farmers themselves have the most to lose by being careless with their animal feed, all these factors conspire to mean that the fears are blown way out of proportion. But who among us would willingly accept even an infinitesimal chance of infection? Fear is not exactly something we can be rationally persuaded out of and the mob mentality has taken over in Korea. Food safety fears similarly fuel the billion dollar plus organic food industry. Lee Myung Bak could publicly eat American steaks and hamburgers for a while and bombard the public with the notion that there is a greater chance of being struck by lightning in a Korean monsoon than eating an infected animal but even then it may be a losing battle.
From the American Perspective...
If Korea backed out of the deal, retaliatory trade measures would then clearly be justifiable. If the US were to slap a block on, for example, Korean cell phones the Koreans protesters' hysterical resolve might melt away pretty quickly and some of the less enlightened Koreans would learn a valuable lesson about trade. Playing hardball with Korea though would hurt both the US and Korea at a time when the US economy is gasping for air, alternatively the US cannot afford to be magnanimous, especially in an election year, and give in to Korean demands. Lee Myung Bak is caught in the middle between public vitriol and the increasingly impatient US congress. Lee Myung Bak will most likely try to play on the fickle nature of the Korean protesters, reshuffle some cabinet members, throw a few bones to the opposition party's demands and announce a new beginning and the protesters, feeling acknowledged will gradually, hopefully run out of enthusiasm and give Lee Myung Bak another chance.
For a mind-blowing, if unnecessarily mocking, look at the history of South Korean protest check this out.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China