The Mexican Revolution and the Visceral Appeal of Socialism
After gaining independence from Spain in 1821, Mexico officially adopted representative and democratic reforms. This was the beginning of a long Mexican tradition of having a constitutional liberal government on paper yet maintaining the centralized, elitist and corporatist structure inherited from the Spanish. Decades later, lower class and indigenous resentment of the authoritarian dictator Santa Anna, as well as resentment of the power of the military and the Catholic Church led to La Reforma led by Mexico’s only true indigenous president, Benito Juarez. The 1857 “reform” constitution, that Juarez and the Liberals then proposed, stressed individual rights and laissez-faire economics, separated church and state and strengthened the legislature while weakening the executive, among other things. By nearly any measure it was very progressive. The proposed changes triggered a three-year “War of Reform” that ended in 1861 with a Liberal victory. However, the Liberals would not get the chance to implement their many reforms. Mexican conservatives, who were desperate not to see their nation fall into the hands of Juarez, pleaded for help from Europe who sent Maximilian of Austria to become emperor of Mexico. The emperor met his demise six years later at the hands of General Porfirio Diaz in the famous battle of Puebla in 1867, which turned Diaz into the “hero of Puebla.” By 1876 Diaz had become president under the banner “no re-election,” nevertheless it marked the beginning of roughly 35 years of ruthless rule known as the Porfiriato. The savvy Diaz’ autocratic rule shepherded by technocrat “científicos” enabled both impressive economic growth and political stability while setting the standard for the authoritarian patronage politics that would typify much of the subsequent rule of Mexico. By 1910, however, the Mexican people’s resentment of the abuse of power was percolating once again as they rallied around Emiliano Zapata, Pancho Villa and Francisco Madero in the beginning of the Mexican Revolution. It was the Mexican Revolution that marked the signal moment in the Mexican national psyche – in its story lie the roots of the social, political and cultural character of contemporary Mexico.

With a balanced budget, massive infrastructural development, booming foreign trade and industrialization taking hold, Porfirio Diaz could legitimately claim to have established order and progress. The economic development, however, lacked entrepreneurialism and a middle class backbone that could sustain the economy without foreign capital and the Porfiriato’s blatant bribery, elimination of the opposition, favoritism and indifference to extreme poverty were more than enough to undermine any widespread support for Diaz, despite macroeconomic success. Furthermore, in contrast to Chile and Argentina, there was not even a middle class coherent enough to create a reformist movement. Workers, however, did begin to strike and protest more and more vehemently in both the cities and the countryside and became particularly enraged when land was taken from the largely illiterate and sometimes starving peasants for commercial agriculture or new railroads. It was these gross inequities that sowed the seeds for a popular uprising with the support made possible by a split within the dominant elite.
Though Diaz surprisingly left Mexico in 1911, leaving the presidency in the hands of Francisco Madero, the Revolution had taken on a life of its own in the hands of Emiliano Zapata who pointed to Madero’s aristocratic upbringing, foreign education and free market thinking as proof that he was no hero of the people. The Zapatistas, in the south, were inspired to reclaim peasant land, with their new aim they reclaimed and aggrandized the Revolution that Madero had started and refashioned it along more radical Marxist lines. Madero ultimately proved to not have the killer-instinct to survive in Mexican politics and was killed by his own military chief of staff, Victoriano Huerta, in 1913, who then assumed power. The Revolution then kicked into high gear. Pancho Villa in the north also announced “agrarian reform” and the confiscation of large haciendas that he used to feed, maintain and arm (with US weapons) his forces, while Zapata’s reclaimed land was returned to their peasant owners. Another politician, Venustiano Carranza, an elite himself, was meanwhile jockeying for power as well and with Carranza, Zapata and Villa, and later the US marines in Veracruz, all intent on bringing down Huerta, the bloody revolution that cost over 1 million lives raged forth.
In the end Carranza, with his political acumen, leftward shifting rhetoric, stronger military commanders and Mexico City power-base proved stronger than Villa and Zapata’s less organized, now regional forces and was able to assume the presidency and then draft the Constitution of 1917. Though Carranza was no ardent socialist himself, the constitutional convention delegates he brought together most certainly were. Land redistribution, labor rights, and church restrictions made this new document shockingly Marxist (before the Russian Revolution) and put Mexican workers and peasants on the political landscape – a feature that would become a defining characteristic of Mexican politics thereafter. Carranza, like Diaz before him, did not allow succession to follow the will of the people and was killed and eventually succeeded by Álvaro Obregón. Now over 10 years in the making, the tumultuous Mexican Revolution began to soul-search. A literary and artistic explosion, including most prominently Diego Rivera, sought to use art as a tool to educate the masses and inspire them to fight. This great struggle of ideas and grappling with reality, had thrown Mexico into the crucible of nationhood. It was during the Mexican Revolution that Mexico became Mexico. All the myths demonizing the Spanish Conquistadores and greedy Americans and exalting the Aztecs (though few are eager to identify themselves as indígena) and indigenous history (though the Aztecs were a war-like, conquering people themselves) and creating the lore that animates and punctuates Mexican political passions to this day. The movement of the Zapatistas that began in 1994 and the Mexican penchant for political literature, music and art are all testament to the lasting influence of the Mexican Revolution.
Politically, Mexico emerged from the Revolution with populist rhetoric, socially with an inflamed and indignant sense of historical grievance and culturally with a uniquely and newly self-aware identity. Though violence had subsided somewhat after 1920, the throes of the Revolution did not really calm until, after the 1928 assassination of Obregon, the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) came into power in 1929, founded by Plutarco Elías Calles. The PRI, under Calles, would restore some stability but was challenged by the Cristeros who objected to the secularization of the deeply Catholic nation. By 1934, Lazaro Cardenas, handpicked by Calles, had come to power and became a hero by denouncing Calles for corruption and deporting him and others to the US. Next he expropriated American oil interests, and redistributed a whopping 44 million acres to landless Mexicans (much of the land was built into ejidos, a type of communal farm), cementing his legacy, along with Juarez and Zapata, among the pantheon of Mexican greats. Agrarian reform was the ultimate among the Revolutionary ideals, even though the ejidos would prove to be less than stellar in terms of production.
The PRI, following the Import-Substitution Industrialization (ISI) model generally saw impressive growth and low inflation for forty years until the 1969 Tlatelolco student massacre at the hands of the PRI that forever demolished any semblance of popular credibility the PRI maintained. Subsequent presidents made few acts of integrity and the PRI became gradually more and more known for its endemic corruption, shameless electoral fraud and ruthless brutality.
To this day, the PRI is a member of Socialist International, though it has proved itself to be more right than socialist, this fact only highlights the necessity of pandering to the leftist sentiments roused by the Revolution and still full of gusto today.
Comments