American Center at Ground Zero of Islam and Zen Diplomacy in Cairo and Manhattan

While the Islamic center debate rolls on, a State Department-funded center at the heart of Sunni Islamic learning – Cairo’s 1,000 year old Al Azhar Mosque and University – quietly prepares for its fourth year of intensive English-language instruction to Azhar junior faculty. It was no coincidence Obama’s historic 2009 address was co-hosted by the historically moderate Al Azhar, whose Sufi Grand Imam Ahmad at-Tayyib – Islam’s closest equivalent to the Pope – issues fatwas (he has consistently condemned terrorism) that resonate throughout the Muslim world. The 2007 creation, then, of the English Language Resource Center (ELRC) was a small but significant diplomatic breakthrough in the battle to win Muslim hearts and minds.

At the ELRC, not only do the sometimes information-insulated future professors of Al Azhar gain the English language skills to join the international academic community, discuss American and Muslim history, government, thinking and customs, they also gain access to the 4/5ths of the internet that is in English (including a vast range of diverse media perspectives). In addition, the ELRC curriculum promotes critical thinking and debate, while exposing Azhar Muslims to American educational methods and concepts like participatory democracy, freedom of speech, and women’s rights. All the while, the American other is humanized by daily face-to-face interactions with three American English Language Fellows (think Fulbrighters with M.A.s in teaching English) that teach and manage the center. The American Fellows, myself included, also learn about Islam and Egyptian culture and build meaningful friendships with Muslim students in a rare up-close and personal experience, helping to bridge the Grand-Canyon-like gap in mutual understanding.

Just as most Americans’ understanding of the Muslim world is circumscribed at the mercy of a news media whose ratings are boosted by fear-mongering and prejudice-affirming images of suicide bombings, terror plots and medieval-like oppression of women, most Egyptian Muslims see images of bloodied, wailing Iraqi, Afghan and Palestinian mothers and children, obscene American wealth, and, in the mind of the pious Muslim, the clearest work of the devil; the irresistible wanton American sexuality of the world of internet porn. What would you think of America if these were the only images you saw? How laughably ignorant and naïve would people have to be to believe that the average American is blood-thirsty, greedy and has orgies on a regular basis? No more ignorant and naïve than Americans who believe that the Taliban represents the entire Muslim world, that all Muslims are closet terrorists, cut the hands off of thieves, beat their wives and burn down schools for girls.

Small wonder then that with these two equally absurd monolithic caricatures of the other in the popular imagination, that the 2007 opening of the ELRC drew criticism and opposition not unlike that created by Park 51 today. A December 2007 article about the opening of the ELRC in the Egyptian English-language Al Ahram Weekly, highlighted skepticism about US intentions, gave grave warnings about the “danger” of the powerful influence of American teachers brainwashing Azhar faculty (they might be seduced by “the American dream and American traditions and concepts”), and leveled the accusation that the ELRC represented a “gradual cultural occupation which will eventually lead to American hegemony over the Al Azhar curricula.”

Many opponents of the ELRC, just like the opponents of the “Ground Zero Mosque,” cast Muslims and Americans as cosmic warriors in a battle of good versus evil, exactly what Bin Laden does. Azhar ELRC students were big enough to look beyond this black and white world view, suspend judgment and take a leap by walking in to the American center curious and ready to learn.

The question of the right to build Park 51 was answered over 200 years ago by our founding fathers and America is a better, bigger nation than that debate. But just because Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf (who visited the ELRC in February) has a right to build a mosque at that location, does not mean he should. Just as Americans have the right to burn the Quran but that does not mean they should. If Park 51 is nothing more than an Islamic center for Muslims, then why would it need to be located so close to the WTC site? Rauf is, at best, naïve if he believes that citing his constitutional right is enough to win over the public opinion of the American people. If, however, Park 51 is a testament to the core American value of pluralism, exhibit A of Muslims’ earnest willingness to openly engage – not just American Christians and Jews in interfaith dialogue as Rauf has so far trumpeted, but any and all Americans. A place to listen, explain and share the Muslim perspective, if it is an arena to frankly address legitimate American fears and uproot misconceptions about Islam and debate constructively, then there is perhaps no better place than Ground Zero.

In a recent speech in Dubai, the good-intentioned Rauf said, “there is no struggle between Islam and America.” If by ‘America’ he means the constitution then he is right. If by ‘America’ he means the people and public opinion then he could not be more out of touch, it is the struggle of our generation. Rather than avoiding the issue and relocating the center, reconceiving the project and renaming it the ‘American Center for Muslim and non-Muslim Dialogue’ and teaming up with a well-established cross-cultural dialogue program like Soliya would address the tension head on, affirming American ideals not threatening them, while undermining Bin Laden’s ideology.

As a Fellow at the ELRC, I am constantly aware of the political backdrop and ongoing tension between America and the Muslim world and recognize that, as a cultural ambassador, it is my responsibility to be a sort of Zen diplomat, calmly answering any and all questions, attacks and criticisms of America, no matter how outrageous or fair, without being defensive, seeking only to inform, invite reflection and help students understand what it’s like to be in an American’s shoes. Sometimes I feel like I am personally on trial for my government’s actions but I welcome the responsibility and would have to be ignorant and naïve to expect anything else. Park 51 could likewise be staffed with Muslims able and willing to act as Zen diplomats for greater mutual understanding.

As the battle to define America rages on, so does the battle to define Islam. The bottom line is, Islam will not go away any more than America will so we better learn to coexist. The sooner we look for common ground, listen and actively seek a deeper understanding of the other, the harder it becomes to justify our hatred and the better chance we will have of handing our children a more peaceful, prosperous world. It is not too late for Rauf to recognize the enormous responsibility and opportunity that has landed on his shoulders and refashion his project. A high-profile forum for education and dialogue at Ground Zero, ideally with prayer areas for other religions, could become a powerful bulwark against both extremism and Islamophobia, spreading tolerance and mutual understanding rather than the enmity and hatred it has stirred up so far. In the words of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. “Hatred can never drive out hatred, only love can do that. Darkness can never drive out darkness, only light can do that.”

Benjamin Kalt, English Language Fellow
Al Azhar University English Language Resource Center

Comments

Osama Hassan said…
Thanks Ben for this explanation and I totally agree with you to stop to be under the mercy of a news media and start to understand each other. And let me explain what I think about comparing ELRC with Ground Zero, they work in the same direction but in different ways, Ground Zero touch very critical point related to Islam in America and it face 9/11 problem with very clear message and this message not directed to limited layer or specific people, actually it is very hard to speak with all kinds of minds and try to deliver a message to persuade sad hearts. In contrast ELRC build good communications but with non-core functions, as ELRC is English learning center. Also ELRC work with who can easy (not always, but almost) accept the others according to his knowledge, from both sides, and I think that the most important thing that ELRC offer that it can create good opportunity to AL-Azhar Muslims to can express them self with west language.
One more thing Ben, about “But just because Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf (who visited the ELRC in February) has a right to build a mosque at that location, does not mean he should” totally agree with you about that. But about “Just as Americans have the right to burn the Quran but that does not mean they should”, let me ask why “Americans have the right to burn the Quran”? And I know you mean that they should not do that. I think that all have full rights to express their opinion about Islam and discuss it with appropriate men. But Quran is belong to Muslims, it is look like you told me you have rights to burn my house, you can ask any Islamic scientist to discuss anything in Quran and told him you do not agree with some things in Quran or with it all. As we believe that our eyes, hands and all of our body’s is like credit given by Allah (God) also same as our all property. We should keep them save and use them with good way. In the same way we believe that Quran is one of most things that Allah gives it for us, so the idea having rights to burn the Quran exactly like having rights to kill us and burn our property.
I hope that I can explain it well and I know that liberty doesn’t mean hurting others, and I believe that freedom without limits is not good place for humans. May be it allowed in law of US to express what you think with whatever way, but I don’t think it includes hurting the other.

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China