Tales of Arab Democracy from Egypt

Nicholas Kristoff, in your article “Unfit for Democracy” you wrote an impassioned plea accusing Westerners who assert that the Arab world is not ready for democracy are bigoted. I have worked in Egypt for the last 18 months at Al Azhar University teaching PhD students English and I have some thoughts I would like to share with you about democracy in the Arab world and specifically in Egypt.

You must understand: It all depends on your definition of democracy.

You wrote, “I’ve been humbled by the lionhearted men and women I’ve seen defying tear gas or bullets for freedom that we take for granted. How can we say that these people are unready for a democracy that they are prepared to die for?”
If you mean to say that thousands of courageous members of a society fighting against oppression qualifies a society as ready for Western-style participatory democracy based on constitutional liberalism with the embedded ideals of freedom of speech, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, freedom of association, etc. then I believe you are sorely out of touch with the reality on the ground in Egypt (the reality of the masses far from Tahrir Square). If you mean that thousands of courageous members of a society fighting against oppression qualifies a society for a government that is more accountable to the needs of its people, more representative, less corrupt and more transparent than you are very right.
If the question is whether or not to have direct elections it is a tough one and a roll of the dice, I sincerely hope you are right that Egypt is ready but I frankly expect that great instability, political infighting and a debilitating power struggle will ensue (if you think Republicans and Democrats are not civil, stay tuned to watch the kind of stubbornness, vitriol and destructive hostility that will burst forth between competing groups in Egypt) and the military will swoop in and restore order just like it did so many times in Turkey. PLEASE write an article comparing Ataturk's ideas, suppression of Islam and the military's role in Turkey over the last 50+ years and the rise of Erdogan to the Egyptian situation today and the future of Egypt (Turkey is just on the verge of being ready now and is 25 years ahead of Egypt in terms of human development).
*I wrote the essay below in early January before the protests began about the ways in which Egypt is not ready for democracy. Of course I advocated Mubarak staying in power because that would have been the best for stability (and I may have been naïve about how willing to reform he was, but I just think he needed a stronger push from Obama, but Obama was too reluctant to be accused of interfering in domestic affairs), and now the people have spoken and change was necessary, but the basic educational, social and human development of the Egyptian lower and lower middle classes still remains largely the same and Egypt is a generation away from what we call democracy in the West with its trappings. Below is what should have happened, the next wise step now is much more difficult to ascertain.

I got a first-hand look at Egyptian democracy as an English Language Fellow organizing elections at our Al Azhar University language center in 2010. Not only were the class representative elections all landslides, but just before each election I walked in on a heated discussion dominated by a few vocal alpha males. What I had witnessed was shura “mutual consultation” – a pre-Islamic and Islamic group decision-making process that is limited to “knowledgeable voices” – seeking ijma “unanimity.” Of course the results were lopsided; shura aims to thwart fitna “chaos” by purging all dissent to achieve social conformity. Just three months after the elections, two of our five classes had unanimously impeached their representatives one for being “unreliable” and the other for “talking to everyone like children” – underscoring the high level of social volatility and the mediocre leaders selected by a popularity contest in a society unaccustomed to leading itself.
The next election determined our center-wide field trip destination. When I announced the winner, two classes that voted near-unanimously for the second place destination defiantly refused to go – a display of the Bedouin prideful jahilliyah or “irascibility” – jeopardizing the whole trip. I then recognized my taken-for-granted Jeffersonian notion of democracy, "Every man cannot have his way in all things. If his opinion prevails at some times, he should acquiesce on seeing that of others preponderate at other times. Without this mutual disposition we are disjointed individuals, not a society." Islam takes the nothing-beyond-my-tribe world view of Arab society and attempts to dissolve it and elevate it to Allah and the collective good of the ummah or “society.” Islam's Ijma – not the messy pluralist democracy and chaos I instigated – is the tailor-made 1,400 year old prescribed cure for Arab tribal fitna, but in Egypt, even in Islamic dress, the tribal mentality still rules.
In the run-up to the Egyptian presidential election, CNN and other Western media will surely champion English-speaking, westernized Egyptian elite, like Mohamed El Baradei, articulately demanding democracy. However, democratic elections are premised on every voice counting, acceptance of diversity, the losers embracing the winners' legitimacy and a modicum of social stability – none of which is present in the Arab tribal ethos of the Egyptian lower and middle classes typified by the Al Azhar demographic. Furthermore, the uproars sparked by church construction, the threatened Quran burning and the Muhammad cartoons illustrated the prevalence of intense jahilliyah vengeance and just how far the Egyptian masses are from internalizing Voltaire's; “I disapprove of what you say but I will defend to the death your right to say it.” Until average citizens are willing to uphold the rights of their enemies in order to safeguard their own – thereby enshrining not only freedoms but civic responsibilities – Egypt is not ready for democracy. Jefferson's words to Lafayette in 1815 after Napoleon smothered the chaos of the French Revolution ring true in Egypt today,
“A full measure of liberty is not now perhaps to be expected by your nation, nor am I confident they are prepared to preserve it. More than a generation will be requisite, under the administration of reasonable laws favoring the progress of knowledge in the general mass of the people, and their habituation to an independent security of person and property, before they will be capable of estimating the value of freedom, and the necessity of a sacred adherence to the principles on which it rests for preservation. Instead of that liberty which takes root and growth in the progress of reason, if recovered by mere force or accident; it becomes, with an unprepared people, a tyranny still, of the many, the few, or the one.”
Instead of pushing destabilizing elections and instead of falling for Mubarak's fear-mongering false dichotomy – “my brutal oppression or terrorists in power and war with Israel” – Obama must boost conditioned economic aid (without cutting military aid) to discreetly broker a Fajr Gideed “New Dawn” program in Egypt. Mubarak's Fajr Gideed would co-opt the Brotherhood and thwart burgeoning radicalism by employing thousands of the Brotherhood at the grass-roots level, capitalizing on their vaunted welfare, health care, youth sports and organizational capacity – putting the restless opposition to work and providing desperately needed social services to the lower classes. Of course, this idea has been floated in the past and tremendous mutual hatred precludes any public Brotherhood-Mubarak collaboration. Fajr Gideed would be introduced with a secular nationalist frame – as a massive new social services program – and proceed to quietly handpick Brothers and other opposition and community leaders by appealing to the prophet Muhammad's ideal of practical compassion, offering jobs and resources to feed, clothe and house the indigent, to establish clinics and hospitals, libraries and literacy programs, youth sports fields and leagues, and other apolitical initiatives that build community without threatening social stability, public safety or the ruling NDP's hold on power in any way. Critical to transforming the image of the government would be a parallel program to eradicate police brutality and later address corruption. Anything less than simultaneously alleviating poverty and cultivating tawhid or “unity” of the Egyptian nation will agitate fitna chaos – exactly the radicalizing social upheaval that is the greatest threat to both Egyptian and ultimately American public safety.
Once ordinary Egyptian citizens start seeing and benefiting from Fajr Gideed services in their communities, the edge would be taken off of radicalism, Egypt could breathe a sigh of relief and, over time, would be able to end over 30 years of the Egyptian police state's emergency law and gradually release political prisoners and allow more criticism of government so long as the Brotherhood maintains severed both its political arm's talk of revolution and its ties to Iran. Egypt would not follow the Iranian or Tunisian path into revolution because Egypt would never put down the hammer, it would just extend a carrot with the other hand. Fajr Gideed would break the inertia and set Egyptian civil society in motion on the long human development journey to democracy – not for this generation but for the next – by bringing the Brotherhood and the Egyptian state together to focus on the truly moderating and empowering elixirs of education, health and prosperity.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China