All Mayors' Eyes on Chicago Infrastructure Trust
Watch Rahm's grand plan on PBS. See more from Need To Know.
A cascade of federal, state and municipal credit rating downgrades and an imminent “fiscal cliff” have squeezed local governments into politically painful spending cuts, tax hikes or both. In Chicago, a city $7 billion in debt, Mayor Rahm Emanuel was struggling to sell general-obligation bonds. With potholed streets, old pipes, inefficient city buildings and dilapidated public transportation, Chicago is like many cities across America. Frustrated by “dysfunctional budgetary politics” and reluctant to raise taxes, Emanuel created the “Chicago Infrastructure Trust” (CIT) to lure private investors into a $7 billion public-private partnership (PPP) that he claims will create jobs and spur growth while rebuilding aging infrastructure. Emanuel turned many mayors' heads with interest from big investors like Citibank, JP Morgan, Real Assets, Macquarie Infrastructure, and union pension fund Ullico to the tune of $1.7 billion in private capital, leaving many wondering; Is Rahm's CIT a new model for cash-strapped cities?How it Works
To reach the $7 billion goal, CIT, a non-profit, draws on traditional funding like municipal bond offerings and higher water and sewer fees as well as private sources. CIT will review a variety of agency proposals and, depending on the project, determine the funding structure. In order to gather the required initial capital outlays, those projects that generate revenue, like fee-based wifi or rapid transit, could be bid on by investors who would thereby secure rights to a revenue stream over a limited period of time, while ownership of projects would remain in government hands. Because private companies are trying to profit they have incentive to keep costs down, finish on time and maintain a revenue stream. To be clear, the infrastructure is not “free.” User-fees are effectively a tax, CIT merely shifts a large initial capital outlay tax burden to a more diffuse per-use tax burden. If leasing an existing government asset, e.g. a toll road, there is a chance of government (and taxpayers) getting 'ripped off,' but with creation of a new asset, e.g. a city-wide wifi network, the government isn't selling anything per se but rather matching public infrastructure needs to private investors on a case-by-case basis, while maintaining long-term ownership of the new infrastructure that it wouldn't even have been able to finance on its own. So if coffers are full then by all means the city should take on sure-fire profitable infrastructure projects itself and provide a public good while reaping profits. But if the city lacks capital, can't secure federal funding or just wants to avoid the risk and a profitable proposal will just gather dust while willing private investors sit on cash, can't a mutually beneficial deal be negotiated?
The Economics
Infrastructure investments have long-term benefits; raising productivity and reducing costs while facilitating agglomeration economies (network effects), economies of scale and human capital development. Also, outside investors may improve efficiency. Additionally, for example, subway ridership and the user-fee the market will bear involves uncertainty, but a PPP can off-load this risk to private investors reducing government exposure to risk. Infrastructure like water, sewage or communications networks are 'natural monopolies' because it's most efficient for production to be concentrated in a single firm. Monopolies, free from competitive pressures, may need to be regulated (e.g. price controls, safety standards, upgrade requirements, oversight mechanisms, no monopoly privileges) for the public good. Designing a competitive bidding process with safeguards against lobbying influence in granting of contracts (and rent-seeking behavior) is critical. Information asymmetry might also occur. Great technical capacity and expertise would be required to write potentially decades-long contracts that protect public interest, otherwise investors may know things government does not and exploitii. Well-designed bidding processes and contracts raise negotiating and administrative costs. In conclusion, CIT can circumvent bureaucracy without raising taxes, stimulate economic activity and facilitate long-term growth but forfeits future revenue stream for short-term budgetary relief. Nonetheless, in tough times, carefully structured PPPs open up new opportunities with manageable risks and therefore demand serious attention from all mayors facing fiscal deficits and crumbling infrastructure.
Comments