Cartoon Uproar Makes Hating Muslims Too Easy

To all of you patriots out there. I assure you Americans still understand freedom of the press as fundamental.
If I were an editor I believe I would have published the cartoons (after the riots) in the interest of telling the story and promoting informed, healthy debate (there should be limits to the protection of incendiary speech, but I think criticizing any religion is fair game). I respect the Muslim belief that the prophet shall not be depicted but I am not bound by that covenant. In the same way that I am not bound by the internal army covenant to salute superior officers. They are not my superior officers and he is not my prophet.
Before the riots (if I were the initial Danish editor) it becomes an editorial question of taste. I do not believe the rioters are feigning indignation. I think they were deeply offended, and many in the Islamic world feel cornered by the West. The cartoons deliberately hit below the belt in the Middle East and violated the 'good faith' with Muslims in Europe. Editors are not obliged to print all the most inflammatory, offensive material that comes their way for the glory of upholding free speech.
Many American editors who practiced self-censorship did so for the wrong reasons, for fear of a backlash, or fear of being labeled racist etc. Of course there is irony by the boatload in Muslims "How-dare-you-call-us-violent!-We'll-show-you-violent!" response. And I agree there is hypocrisy in light of the Middle Eastern press' shameless attacks on other religions.
We should not send the message that if you're violent enough we will stop criticizing you. Nor should we turn our flamethrowers to the issue for the sake of proving that point.
The fact is, political cartoons are supposed to poignantly strike nerves, they are supposed to exaggerate, to be edgy, even offensive if they make a valid point. Whether or not the cartoons made a valid point is debatable.
Finally, the riots are a manifestation of Islamist supremacism, but remember that Christianity also damns non-believers and Judaism certainly isnt above supremacy either.
The average American has watched the violence and thought "Damn, Muslims are fuckin nuts."I do not claim to fully understand the Muslim reaction, and admittedly its shocking but thats what makes it so much more interesting for the intellectually curious.
I will not succumb to the comforts of prejudice and I will never give up trying to understand that which is most vexing to me. Too many Americans are content to give up and embrace hatred. America is a better nation than that.
Please try for 5 minutes to really put yourself in a Middle Eastern Muslim's shoes.
Comments