Hydrogen Economy?


There is a great deal of misinformation regarding the viability of hydrogen as the energy source of the future. Here are the facts:

Hydrogen has about 2 ½ times the energy potential of gasoline (per gram, kilogram).
Hydrogen, however, is typically a gas not a liquid (like oil) and gas has about 1000 times less mass than liquid.
So a gallon of hydrogen gas (1000 times less massive than liquid gasoline) has about 1/400 the energy potential of a gallon of liquid gasoline. Hydrogen, however, can be compressed. But even when it is compressed it is not as dense as gasoline (roughly 1/5), so even liquid hydrogen has about 1/2 to 1/3 the energy potential of liquid gasoline. Of course, technology for compressing hydrogen even more could be developed in the future, that technology is vital for the creation of a large scale hydrogen economy.

*liquid hydrogen would be much more explosive and dangerous than gasoline, and further compression would only increase that danger

Basically as a compact, portable, efficient fuel source, oil is unmatched, thats why we are "addicted to oil".

Right now, you can probably drive around 300 miles on a full tank of gas. To drive 300 miles on liquid hydrogen you'd need a gas tank almost as big as your car. But if you only need to go very short distances or don't mind stopping to refuel every hour or so (highway driving) then it has value (large natural gas tanks, in addition to a regular gasoline tank, in car trunks are common in Argentina but a full tank only gets you about 60 miles (albeit for less than $1).
Furthermore, if a gas tank as big as a car or larger is not a problem (i.e. bus, big truck or airplane) then hydrogen is a more viable energy source because it takes up so much space (some city buses in Sacramento, CA currently run on hydrogen).

Loose hydrogen (H²) gas does not exist in great quantities in our atmosphere or in the earth. It cannot be mined like oil. Most hydrogen today is obtained by burning coal (carbon) C + 2H²O=CO²+2H²
Obviously this is not an improvement over fossil fuels because you need a fossil fuel to make it happen and you still produce CO² (Hydrogen can be harvested from methane too, but, again, CO² is released).
Our greatest source of hydrogen is bound up in water, it can also be harvested through a process called electrolysis (running electricity through water to separate H² and O²). This is not a great option either because electricity is required, and it is not terribly efficient because heat (energy) is wasted in the process.
Basically another energy source is required to obtain hydrogen.


Hydrogen fuel cells essentially utilize reverse electrolysis(H² and O² are fused into water which releases electricity) and are about 40% efficient (60% of the energy is lost) in storing energy. This technology is actually currently viable because energy from a nuclear power plant (or any other power plant) that is generated at night (when consumers don't use much energy) can be stored in fuel cells and then be available during peak hours (no more rolling blackouts like California had). 40% is better than nothing.

Another potential use of hydrogen is battery replacement. Batteries are relatively inefficient and your laptop or Ipod probably only works for a few hours. Miniature hydrogen fuel cells have a much better energy/weight ratio and could conceivably give you 15 hours to use your laptop (because only a very small amount of energy is required, compared to say running a car engine).

High oil prices create huge demand for this technology and other alternative energies and huge demand prompts huge investment. In the short term, oil prices will probably not stay terribly high ($60 +) because oil producers (mainly OPEC) limit supply to increase profit margins, but they understand they'd lose big if the economy were to shift away from oil, so they will increase supply (as far as its possible) until a lower price of oil discourages massive alternative energy research/investment.

Before the hydrogen economy comes, coal is the biggest threat to oil's dominance (the US has enough coal to last 500 years, China has a lot too) and coal can be converted to gasoline at around $40 a barrel. Historically oil prices have been below $30 a barrel so there was no incentive for massive conversion plants to be built. If prices looked to settle at or above $50/bbl ($30 + coal costs + capital outlay) for the foreseeable future, massive investment in coal conversion facilities in the US would become more likely. A New York Times article talks about the lobbying push for government to guarantee the viability of coal gasification in the name of energy independence.

Solar energy, about 1 sq. km of bright sunlight has about 1 gigawatt (1,000 kilowatts) of energy, that is about the same as a coal or nuclear plant of similar size produces, the problem, however, is even the best solar panels we have today can only convert about 15% of that energy into usable energy. Solar-powered cars will never be viable because 1 sq. meter solar panel produces about 1 horsepower. So somehow jam 3 sq. meters of solar panels on a ridiculous looking car and you have a 3 hp car, about 1/20th of the power of a little Geo Metro.
If you want to be more efficient in your energy use, go out and buy a bunch of fluorescent light bulbs, they are way more efficient users of energy (because they don't waste so much heat energy) and they last longer.
And to those who ascribe to the "Peak Oil" doomsday notion, we have 5 times more oil available on the earth than mankind has used to date, we are not running out of oil, we are running out of cheap oil, at higher prices we can turn to oil shale, oil in the arctic and other hard or expensive to get at sources. Even at just $40 a barrel (much lower than prices have been this year) we have plenty of oil for 100 years or more.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China