The Coming "Population Crunch"?

"In every deliberation we must consider the impact on the seventh generation."
Great Law of the Iroquois
Not long ago it was difficult to dispute the notion that exponential population growth would inevitably outrun the earth's finite resources leading to a “Malthusian Crunch.” Widespread famines, resource wars, dropping oxygen levels, mass extinctions, unraveling ecosystems, epidemics, poisonous air, soil and water were all predicted. Perpetual population explosion meant doomsday was just around the corner. Then something curious began to happen. Fertility rates began to fall. The phenomena surfaced everywhere from Japan to Poland to India to Russia to Italy to Namibia to Australia to Brazil. Never have fertility rates fallen so far, so fast, so low, for so long, all over the world, yielding populations in decline. People are having fewer children, not because of disease or famine or governmental regulations, but because they choose to, perhaps because more children are more expensive to raise and when city life and education become a factor, fewer children mean a better life for the family.
Fertility rates in the entire developed world (with the statistical anomaly of the US) have now dropped below “replacement level” (2.1 births per/woman) to around, on average, 1.6 and falling, which means populations are not only NOT growing, they are beginning to shrink. Furthermore, the phenomena is prevalent in the less developed world. There are already 21 less developed countries with fertility rates below replacement levels including China, Mexico and Thailand. Several others' rates have fallen rapidly to near replacement level and continue to drop: Brazil, from 6.25 to 2.25; Turkey, from 6.9 to 2.2; Tunisia, from 7.2 to 2.3; Indonesia, from 5.6 to 2.7. Conversely, of the 50 or so countries apparently most removed from this trend (with fertility rates above 4.2) 43 are in Africa and all 50 are marginalized from the global economy. So there may be two worlds, the marginalized, stagnant world and the developed (or developing) world. The developed world is now struggling with population implosion, implementing tax incentives in an attempt to stimulate the lowest birthrates ever recorded and, thereby, hoping to mitigate the looming budgetary shortfalls of aging welfare states, while the marginalized world remains in the Malthusian scenario. Population projections that do not sufficiently account for these changes and the concomitant demographic transition are mere extrapolations. In a nutshell, development = lower fertility rates: the most successful population reduction program is development.
Many population projections that account for the demographic flux brought about by development and globalization predict that the global population will peak around 2030 at 8 billion and then will begin to decline. A fall in global population would be a godsend in terms of environmental and resource strain, so global development must be the goal. All we need to do, is develop the whole world and then over-population problems will begin to take care of themselves. Of course that is easier said than done but we really don't have a choice. The question then becomes can the earth withstand the imminent resource crunch and environmental degradation of the global rush towards development? Or will the cost of global development be the destruction of a livable planet? So while development is the solution it is also the problem, it is developed nations that gobble up the most resources and pollute the most. So unless the model of development changes as well, global development will only exacerbate our ecological problems.
While there is obviously a correlation between the sheer population of a society and that society's adverse impact on the health of the planet, we must remember that all polluters and consumers are not created equal. Some consume less than others, some pollute less, some recycle more. Population in and of itself is not the problem, population takes the consumption patterns and ecological footprint of a society and multiplies it – population is merely the exponent. We have already severely damaged our planet, however, there is still much to be preserved. Above all, governments must foment accelerated development and the developed world must lead by example, finding innovative ways to be both ecologically responsible and prosperous.
Developing the less developed world does not mean you have to run out and join the Peace Corps and move to the Congo. The less developed world is probably in your town. The US is a statistical anomaly because neglecting lower classes is built into the system. In effect, “less developed countries” exist all over the United States. Detroit, for example, has infant mortality rates that compare with some sub-Saharan African countries. Inner cities, rural areas and large areas in the south have unemployment, crime, poverty, illiteracy and health issues like the less developed world (not to mention the poverty found on Indian reservations). Targeting over-population directly (apart from sex education, “two-child family” campaigns and contraception) run contrary to the foundations of a free society and can no longer be taken seriously (outside of totalitarian regimes willing to trample human rights).
Finally, all population and environmental issues are global issues. Immigration is a result of a lack of development elsewhere and a lack of development elsewhere is our problem because we all share the earth. To focus exclusively on the US as if we somehow did not exist within a global context is not only foolish, it is detrimental to our goals. Xenophobes parading as environmentalists and nationalism at the expense of our neighbors is the refuge of small minds. Throughout history, countries that have built walls around themselves trying to resist changes in the world around them have stagnated and digressed. America is a better nation than that, we tear down walls. Should the United States government pursue population policies to protect our quality of life for future generations? Human fertility takes care of itself with development/education and migration is an absurd fixation of parochial Americans so the answer is an emphatic no, we must attack the roots of the problem, we owe that magnanimity to our great, great, great, great, great grandchildren.
For a more extensive look at declining population check out this New York Times 10-page article.
Comments