Time to take down the Statue of Liberty?
"Give me your tired, your poor,
your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
the wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"
Nothing makes my chest swell more, nothing makes me prouder to be an American than the magnanimity embodied by the Statue of Liberty. I am from Tucson, Arizona just an hour from Mexico and I am for open borders. I love the culture, music, food, diversity and energy that immigrants breathe into America. I love Mexico. You will not find many more pro-immigration than me.

That is precisely why I am so vexed by images of masses of immigrants waving the flags of Mexico, Ecuador, Colombia among others. How can they be waving flags from their home country as they march to become part of America?
Why aren't they waving the American flag? Admittedly many do get it. There are sometimes American flags in the crowd. But the panoply of, primarily Latin American, flags is utterly bewildering. Undoubtedly it is an expression of pride. But how can that Mexican pride and even nationalism be reconciled with an "American identity"? What is the difference between mass immigration and invasion? Is America merely a geographical area up for grabs? America has, historically, proven itself to be an incredibly solvent nation. America has an uncanny ability to absorb and incorporate any race, any belief system, any language, any culture, find common ground and somehow emerge strong, unified and amazingly, ever more American. Assimilation has been what has made America coherent, it is what makes America America. Waving a foreign flag as you demand to become American is a brash rejection of assimilation and portends a battle for the American identity.
Everything is in flux, traditional notions of "country" are morphing. Is America really a country? Is the term country still relevant in today's discourse? Does "country" even matter anymore?
America will have to find a way to prudently address these burgeoning questions, and fast, or an already combustible situation could erupt into a national crisis. I have racked my brain and I cannot find a valid justification for brandishing only foreign flags as you ask for acceptance in America.
So to all of those of you ready to march in your rallies take a moment and really think about who you are, who you want to be and what it is you are asking for. Keep your Latin American flags, they are part of who you are and you should be proud of where you come from but get an American flag too, that is part of who you are too and you should be proud of your American identity as well. If you are headed to a rally carry your Latin American flag in one hand and your American flag in the other. If you do that I will welcome you and stand shoulder to shoulder with you in your fight for rights and respect, you can speak Spanish (though an effort to learn English shows respect for the culture and people), you can form communities and maintain your culture, you can love or despise President Bush, but, right or wrong, you must accept America if you want America to accept you.
For more on the economics of immigration and a definitive answer to whether or not immigrants "take more than they give" to America read this Open Letter on Immigration to Pres. Bush from the Independent Institute
Comments
much less the people who believed the land was stolen from them originally.
earthica star*