Inequity: The Cancer of American Education & Looking Beyond the Classroom
Teacher's College
Located on the edge of Harlem in uptown Manhattan, the historic mission of Columbia University's graduate school of education, Teacher's College (TC), has been to serve urban and disadvantaged populations. In 2004 the college reaffirmed this commitment to combat the "Achievement Gap" - the chasm in access, expectation, and outcomes in education between low-income and high-income populations; whites/Asians and blacks/Hispanics; urban and suburban residents, etc.
This year, incoming TC students received Richard Rothstein's book Class and Schools: Using Social, Economic, and Educational Reform to Close the Black-White Achievement Gap (Rothstein is a research associate of the Economic Policy Institute and a former NY Times columnist) as a sort of intro/primer on the core mission of TC. This book is particularly relevant to schools across America in light of the federal mandate "No Child Left Behind" - that ALL children will be proficient on state tests in math, reading and science by 2014. The book's thesis is that raising the achievement of lower-class children requires that public policy address social and economic conditions of these children's lives, not just school reform.
In other words "failing schools" are only part of the problem, social class characteristics are, in fact, the single-most powerful predictor of scholastic achievement. The more stable, supportive, educated and high-income the family, the better the child will do in school - families and communities matter. This should be obvious to anyone who has considered the problem, but it is not adequately, if at all, reflected on the ground level or in government and school policy.
The book's value is in fleshing out the details of just how a lower-class child's upbringing is, on average, different from a typical middle-class child's upbringing, suggesting possible solutions and trying to pound this paradigm into the heads of policy makers.
Social Class Differences: Problems
Examples of differences abound. Lower-class children, on average, have poorer vision, poorer oral hygiene, more lead poisoning, more asthma, poorer nutrition, less adequate pediatric care, more exposure to smoke and a host of other health problems - not only do they miss more days of school, they are not as ready and able to learn when they are in class. Furthermore, in large part due to the lack of affordable low-income housing, lower-class children, on average, change homes and schools much more frequently than middle-class children - disrupting curricular and social continuity and jarring children's confidence. In addition, children of lower social classes generally exhibit more anti-social behavior than children of higher social classes, both in early childhood and in adolescence.
Reading to Children
Most parents in America appreciate the importance of reading to develop their very young children's minds, but middle and upper-class parents read more books, read in greater variety and read in more intellectually stimulating ways. Perhaps surprisingly, lower-class parents give more explicit training and drills in number and letter recognition, letter-sound correspondence etc. than do middle-class parents. Fewer surveyed middle-class parents (than lower-class) thought these skills were necessary for entering kindergartners and were generally confident that raising children in an environment where literacy was valued and modeled would be a more important determinant of children's own literacy than drilling these children in the basics.
If children see parents reading to solve their own problems, reading material from work or reading for pleasure, children are more likely to want to read themselves. How parents read to children is as important as whether they do; when working-class parents read aloud they are more likely to tell children to pay attention without interruptions or to sound out words or name letters. When they ask children about a story, questions are more likely to be factual, asking for names of objects or memories of events. More literate parents are more likely to ask questions that are creative, interpretive, or connective, like “What do you think will happen next?” “Why do you think this happened?” “Does that remind you of what we did yesterday?" Middle-class parents are more likely to read aloud to have fun, to start conversations, to provide a segue to discussing the world outside. Their children learn reading is enjoyable and are more motivated to read in school.
Studies in the rural South found that lower-class black parents made a deliberate effort to teach pre-verbal children to name objects and to speak, but then were more likely than white working-class parents to abandon this activity once the children began talking; the black parents were more likely to view the job of teaching children to speak as now having been accomplished. Finally, explaining events and any and everything relevant to the child's life in the broader world during meals etc. can have as much of a positive influence as early reading.
More Class by Class Variations
Even computer use significantly varies by class. By kindergarten, almost all upper-class children, about half of middle-class children and fewer than one in five lower-class children have used computers. Furthermore upper and middle-class parents routinely sit their toddlers on their laps and allow them to play with the mouse and keyboard. These children enter kindergarten with a definite advantage in computer skills.
Additionally, all the way to adulthood, these (typically) social class based differences potentially influence character traits like perseverance, self-confidence, self-discipline, punctuality, communication skills, social responsibility and the ability to work with others and resolve conflicts. Econometric studies show that these "non-cognitive" skills are a stronger predictor of future earnings than are test scores.
Education: From Pregnancy to Adulthood
Most of the social class difference in average academic potential exists by the time children are three years old. On average, professional parents speak over 2,000 words per hour to their children, working-class parents speak about 1,300 and welfare mothers speak about 600. So by age 3, children of professionals have vocabularies that were nearly 50% greater than those of working-class children and twice as large as those of welfare children. By 3 years of age, the children of professionals had larger vocabularies themselves than the vocabularies used by adults from welfare families in speaking to their children. Eye contact, questions, singing, frequently changing the tone of voice, volume and speed of speaking and expressing emotion through facial expressions also stimulate children and aid mental development and vocabulary growth and retention.
Discipline also differs. Toddlers of professionals get an average of six encouragements per reprimand, working-class children get two and for welfare children the ratio is reversed, an average of one encouragement for two prohibitions.
Apples don't fall far from the tree
Upper-middle-class parents generally have jobs where they are expected to collaborate with fellow employees, create new solutions to problems, or wonder how to improve their contributions, they are more likely to talk to their children differently than lower-class parents whose jobs simply require them to follow instructions without question. Fostering inquisitiveness at home has huge payoffs in the classroom.
Parents whose occupations required creativity and decision making were less likely to punish their children for actions where the children's intent was desirable, parents whose occupations were routine and closely supervised were more likely to base punishment on the children's actions themselves, regardless of intent. Soon after middle-class children become verbal, parents typically draw them into adult conversations so children can practice expressing their own opinions, children then feel more comfortable addressing adults as equals and without deference. Children who want reasons rather than simply submitting to direction on adult authority develop intellectual skills upon which later academic success depends. Working-class parents, in contrast, typically maintain firmer boundaries between adult and child worlds and are less likely to conduct conversations with pre-verbal children, except when it is necessary to give a warning or instructions.
Parents whose professional occupations entail authority and responsibility believe more strongly that they can affect their environment and solve problems. At work, they explore alternatives and negotiate compromises. They naturally express these personality traits at home when they design activities where children figure out solutions for themselves. Even the youngest middle-class children practice these traits that make academic success more likely when they negotiate what to wear and eat. When middle-class parents give orders, the parents are more likely to explain why the rules are reasonable. Parents whose jobs entail following orders or doing routine tasks are less likely to encourage children to choose their own clothing or food.
Defining the Gap
Even if schools could, theoretically, educate all children equally, children come to school unequal, their home lives are unequal, generally due to social class. In other words, if, for example, on day one of high school (or at any grade level), lower-class students are "70% proficient" (according to state testing measures) and middle-class students are "80% proficient," by the end of the year the middle-class students might be "95% proficient" and the lower-class students might be "85% proficient" but the 10% achievement gap from the start of the year remains. So schools do raise proficiency levels but not disproportionately for lower-class students, enabling them to catch up. A great teacher might make them 115% proficient and 105% proficient respectively, but the gap persists (of course raising the baseline for lower-class children irrespective of their middle-class counterparts is a success in its own right). Actually, not only can lower-class students not catch up, or close the gap, lower-class students tend to fall further behind because they are not as prepared for learning and don't learn as quickly. Furthermore, primary school testing generally measures only basic skills, middle school and high school testing covers more complex reasoning and critical thinking, so pre-existing gaps in previously untested abilities surface later on, exacerbating the measured gap. To close the black-white achievement gap, schools would have to educate unequally - focusing more on the "bottom half" of the class, presumably dragging down the highest achievers while pulling up the lowest and thereby “closing the gap.”
Looking Beyond the Classroom: The Solutions
Repairing and upgrading school facilities, raising teacher salaries to recruit better teachers, reducing class sizes, emphasizing creativity and reasoning as well as basic skills, holding schools accountable for student performance, creating a focused disciplined and orderly learning environment all benefit students, but they are not enough – we must look beyond the classroom. Raising the minimum wage and an earned income tax credit (a subsidy to low-income working parents with children) could alleviate some of the financial burden and give low-income parents a better chance to provide for their children and enhance their potental, such moves should be seen as educational policies as well as economic policies. Investment should be lopsided towards pre-natal education, pre-natal health care for mothers-to-be and early childhood programs for infants and toddlers. The evidence is mounting that the years before children enter kindergarten are the most decisive and crucial time of their development. Properly directed investment (towards social class rather than exclusively to schools) could eventually deliver solid returns, making a neglected lower class more productive.
Another central idea of Rothstein's is that we must expand the definition of schooling to include those crucial out-of-school hours (after-school and summer). Organized athletics, dance, drama, museum visits, trips to the zoo, recreational reading, and other fun activities develop children's self-confidence, inquisitiveness, self-awareness, creativity, self-discipline, and organizational skills, those are the priorities, they can close the gap. After-school programs that over-focus on remedial instruction and drills do not develop children in this way. Forming or expanding alliances and tutoring/recreation programs with area university's could tap the large pool of University students looking to build their resumes and capable or fostering a stimulating learning environment.
Closing the gap entirely is a bit like world peace, just because we may never make it doesn't mean we should stop trying to get there.
It really does take a village to raise a child.
You can get the book here
and there is a NY Times article here about the book.
You can also email the author at rr2159@columbia.edu
Located on the edge of Harlem in uptown Manhattan, the historic mission of Columbia University's graduate school of education, Teacher's College (TC), has been to serve urban and disadvantaged populations. In 2004 the college reaffirmed this commitment to combat the "Achievement Gap" - the chasm in access, expectation, and outcomes in education between low-income and high-income populations; whites/Asians and blacks/Hispanics; urban and suburban residents, etc.
This year, incoming TC students received Richard Rothstein's book Class and Schools: Using Social, Economic, and Educational Reform to Close the Black-White Achievement Gap (Rothstein is a research associate of the Economic Policy Institute and a former NY Times columnist) as a sort of intro/primer on the core mission of TC. This book is particularly relevant to schools across America in light of the federal mandate "No Child Left Behind" - that ALL children will be proficient on state tests in math, reading and science by 2014. The book's thesis is that raising the achievement of lower-class children requires that public policy address social and economic conditions of these children's lives, not just school reform.
In other words "failing schools" are only part of the problem, social class characteristics are, in fact, the single-most powerful predictor of scholastic achievement. The more stable, supportive, educated and high-income the family, the better the child will do in school - families and communities matter. This should be obvious to anyone who has considered the problem, but it is not adequately, if at all, reflected on the ground level or in government and school policy.
The book's value is in fleshing out the details of just how a lower-class child's upbringing is, on average, different from a typical middle-class child's upbringing, suggesting possible solutions and trying to pound this paradigm into the heads of policy makers.
Social Class Differences: Problems
Examples of differences abound. Lower-class children, on average, have poorer vision, poorer oral hygiene, more lead poisoning, more asthma, poorer nutrition, less adequate pediatric care, more exposure to smoke and a host of other health problems - not only do they miss more days of school, they are not as ready and able to learn when they are in class. Furthermore, in large part due to the lack of affordable low-income housing, lower-class children, on average, change homes and schools much more frequently than middle-class children - disrupting curricular and social continuity and jarring children's confidence. In addition, children of lower social classes generally exhibit more anti-social behavior than children of higher social classes, both in early childhood and in adolescence.
Reading to Children
Most parents in America appreciate the importance of reading to develop their very young children's minds, but middle and upper-class parents read more books, read in greater variety and read in more intellectually stimulating ways. Perhaps surprisingly, lower-class parents give more explicit training and drills in number and letter recognition, letter-sound correspondence etc. than do middle-class parents. Fewer surveyed middle-class parents (than lower-class) thought these skills were necessary for entering kindergartners and were generally confident that raising children in an environment where literacy was valued and modeled would be a more important determinant of children's own literacy than drilling these children in the basics.
If children see parents reading to solve their own problems, reading material from work or reading for pleasure, children are more likely to want to read themselves. How parents read to children is as important as whether they do; when working-class parents read aloud they are more likely to tell children to pay attention without interruptions or to sound out words or name letters. When they ask children about a story, questions are more likely to be factual, asking for names of objects or memories of events. More literate parents are more likely to ask questions that are creative, interpretive, or connective, like “What do you think will happen next?” “Why do you think this happened?” “Does that remind you of what we did yesterday?" Middle-class parents are more likely to read aloud to have fun, to start conversations, to provide a segue to discussing the world outside. Their children learn reading is enjoyable and are more motivated to read in school.
Studies in the rural South found that lower-class black parents made a deliberate effort to teach pre-verbal children to name objects and to speak, but then were more likely than white working-class parents to abandon this activity once the children began talking; the black parents were more likely to view the job of teaching children to speak as now having been accomplished. Finally, explaining events and any and everything relevant to the child's life in the broader world during meals etc. can have as much of a positive influence as early reading.
More Class by Class Variations
Even computer use significantly varies by class. By kindergarten, almost all upper-class children, about half of middle-class children and fewer than one in five lower-class children have used computers. Furthermore upper and middle-class parents routinely sit their toddlers on their laps and allow them to play with the mouse and keyboard. These children enter kindergarten with a definite advantage in computer skills.
Additionally, all the way to adulthood, these (typically) social class based differences potentially influence character traits like perseverance, self-confidence, self-discipline, punctuality, communication skills, social responsibility and the ability to work with others and resolve conflicts. Econometric studies show that these "non-cognitive" skills are a stronger predictor of future earnings than are test scores.
Education: From Pregnancy to Adulthood
Most of the social class difference in average academic potential exists by the time children are three years old. On average, professional parents speak over 2,000 words per hour to their children, working-class parents speak about 1,300 and welfare mothers speak about 600. So by age 3, children of professionals have vocabularies that were nearly 50% greater than those of working-class children and twice as large as those of welfare children. By 3 years of age, the children of professionals had larger vocabularies themselves than the vocabularies used by adults from welfare families in speaking to their children. Eye contact, questions, singing, frequently changing the tone of voice, volume and speed of speaking and expressing emotion through facial expressions also stimulate children and aid mental development and vocabulary growth and retention.
Discipline also differs. Toddlers of professionals get an average of six encouragements per reprimand, working-class children get two and for welfare children the ratio is reversed, an average of one encouragement for two prohibitions.
Apples don't fall far from the tree
Upper-middle-class parents generally have jobs where they are expected to collaborate with fellow employees, create new solutions to problems, or wonder how to improve their contributions, they are more likely to talk to their children differently than lower-class parents whose jobs simply require them to follow instructions without question. Fostering inquisitiveness at home has huge payoffs in the classroom.
Parents whose occupations required creativity and decision making were less likely to punish their children for actions where the children's intent was desirable, parents whose occupations were routine and closely supervised were more likely to base punishment on the children's actions themselves, regardless of intent. Soon after middle-class children become verbal, parents typically draw them into adult conversations so children can practice expressing their own opinions, children then feel more comfortable addressing adults as equals and without deference. Children who want reasons rather than simply submitting to direction on adult authority develop intellectual skills upon which later academic success depends. Working-class parents, in contrast, typically maintain firmer boundaries between adult and child worlds and are less likely to conduct conversations with pre-verbal children, except when it is necessary to give a warning or instructions.
Parents whose professional occupations entail authority and responsibility believe more strongly that they can affect their environment and solve problems. At work, they explore alternatives and negotiate compromises. They naturally express these personality traits at home when they design activities where children figure out solutions for themselves. Even the youngest middle-class children practice these traits that make academic success more likely when they negotiate what to wear and eat. When middle-class parents give orders, the parents are more likely to explain why the rules are reasonable. Parents whose jobs entail following orders or doing routine tasks are less likely to encourage children to choose their own clothing or food.
Defining the Gap
Even if schools could, theoretically, educate all children equally, children come to school unequal, their home lives are unequal, generally due to social class. In other words, if, for example, on day one of high school (or at any grade level), lower-class students are "70% proficient" (according to state testing measures) and middle-class students are "80% proficient," by the end of the year the middle-class students might be "95% proficient" and the lower-class students might be "85% proficient" but the 10% achievement gap from the start of the year remains. So schools do raise proficiency levels but not disproportionately for lower-class students, enabling them to catch up. A great teacher might make them 115% proficient and 105% proficient respectively, but the gap persists (of course raising the baseline for lower-class children irrespective of their middle-class counterparts is a success in its own right). Actually, not only can lower-class students not catch up, or close the gap, lower-class students tend to fall further behind because they are not as prepared for learning and don't learn as quickly. Furthermore, primary school testing generally measures only basic skills, middle school and high school testing covers more complex reasoning and critical thinking, so pre-existing gaps in previously untested abilities surface later on, exacerbating the measured gap. To close the black-white achievement gap, schools would have to educate unequally - focusing more on the "bottom half" of the class, presumably dragging down the highest achievers while pulling up the lowest and thereby “closing the gap.”
Looking Beyond the Classroom: The Solutions
Repairing and upgrading school facilities, raising teacher salaries to recruit better teachers, reducing class sizes, emphasizing creativity and reasoning as well as basic skills, holding schools accountable for student performance, creating a focused disciplined and orderly learning environment all benefit students, but they are not enough – we must look beyond the classroom. Raising the minimum wage and an earned income tax credit (a subsidy to low-income working parents with children) could alleviate some of the financial burden and give low-income parents a better chance to provide for their children and enhance their potental, such moves should be seen as educational policies as well as economic policies. Investment should be lopsided towards pre-natal education, pre-natal health care for mothers-to-be and early childhood programs for infants and toddlers. The evidence is mounting that the years before children enter kindergarten are the most decisive and crucial time of their development. Properly directed investment (towards social class rather than exclusively to schools) could eventually deliver solid returns, making a neglected lower class more productive.
Another central idea of Rothstein's is that we must expand the definition of schooling to include those crucial out-of-school hours (after-school and summer). Organized athletics, dance, drama, museum visits, trips to the zoo, recreational reading, and other fun activities develop children's self-confidence, inquisitiveness, self-awareness, creativity, self-discipline, and organizational skills, those are the priorities, they can close the gap. After-school programs that over-focus on remedial instruction and drills do not develop children in this way. Forming or expanding alliances and tutoring/recreation programs with area university's could tap the large pool of University students looking to build their resumes and capable or fostering a stimulating learning environment.
Closing the gap entirely is a bit like world peace, just because we may never make it doesn't mean we should stop trying to get there.
It really does take a village to raise a child.
You can get the book here
and there is a NY Times article here about the book.
You can also email the author at rr2159@columbia.edu

Comments