Islam vs. The West--Why are they so sensitive?


Angry protestors continue to take to the streets in Indonesia, Iraq, Kashmir, and the Palestinian territories, among other places, expressing outrage and unsatisfied with the Pope Benedict XVI's recent "apology," for remarks he made last Tuesday in Germany. The Pope quoted a 14th century Byzantine emperor, "Show me just what Muhammad brought that was new, and there you will find things only evil and inhuman, such as his command to spread by the sword the faith he preached," read the speech and the only hint of papal disavowal is a description of the emperor's "startling brusqueness". Which means the Pope was either inept, failing to fully disown the emperor's sentiment effectively, or that he in fact agreed with it and wanted to say so. The Pope's larger message was of course that faith cannot be spread by force, "there is no compulsion in religion," but he, of all people, should have foreseen the fallout of using Muhammad as his example.
Unfortunately it appears that the surest way to provoke a violent reaction from Muslim groups is to call them violent.
It is not hard to see why that might be offensive in the current geo-political climate, many Muslims feel cornered by Western capitalism's encroachment and threatened by its military might (at least partially because civilians are being killed by the thousands in Iraq). Pakistan's president, Pervez Musharraf, spoke of "sinister tendencies to associate terror with Islam" which gave rise to an "alienation with the West". In an unusual move for a Pope, days later, he said he was "deeply sorry" Muslims were offended and angered, stressing that the quotation at issue didn't "in any way express my personal thought."
Major Arab television networks devoted much coverage to the Pope's Sunday message; the Al-Arabiya network carried it live. Initial reaction from Islamic groups was mixed, with many saying they still want a fuller apology.
In the aftermath, the son of Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi has called on Pope Benedict XVI to "convert to Islam immediately." An extremist group, The Mujahadeen Shura Council, said, "you and the West are doomed as you can see from the defeat in Iraq, Afghanistan, Chechnya and elsewhere. ... We will break up the cross, spill the liquor and impose head tax, then the only thing acceptable is a conversion (to Islam) or (death by) the sword." Islam forbids drinking alcohol and requires non-Muslims to pay a head tax to safeguard their lives if conquered by Muslims. They are exempt if they convert to Islam. Al-Qaeda in Iraq warned Pope Benedict XVI on Monday that its war against Christianity and the West will go on until Islam takes over the world, and Iran's supreme leader called for more protests over the pontiff's remarks on Islam.

Many bewildered Americans remember the Muhammed cartoon uproar and think, "Here we go again, God Muslims really are just frickin crazy!" Or at the very least, that Muslims are "uniquely touchy."

First off, in Islam, like in Hinduism and Judaism, religion is a more primary source of identity than in most Western societies. It is a mistake to consider Muslimness as merely an adherence to a set of abstract principles (like typical religious affiliation in the West). It is inextricably tied up with culture, folklore, tradition, kinship and frequently nation, it is more like a religio-ethnicity-nationality (some Muslims don't even fully subscribe to the tenets of Islam, yet strongly identify themselves as Muslim). So a slur on Islam is experienced much more like a racist insult. Finally, giving disproportionate airtime to the Islamic extremists means moderate voices often go unheard. The majority have families and want peace but they do not make headlines.
The Pope, of all people, should have damn well known better. What could be worse for the world than an all-out Religious war between Christianity's estimated 2.1 billion and the Muslim world's 1.5 billion? Who on earth is in a better position to steer the world away from such a "clash of civilizations?" All things considered, What a mindblowingly stupid thing to say.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China