Minuteman Project

The Minuteman Project (MP), invited by the Columbia College Republicans, came to speak at Columbia University Wednesday night. The vigilante, gun-toting, illegal immigrant (or undocumented migrant, depending on your leanings) hunting, border patrolling group (condemned by Bush but lauded by Schwarzenegger) was coming into hostile territory. Ivy leaguers are notoriously liberal and pro-immigrant and days before the event, protests and chalk writings on the sidewalk were seen around campus. "Patriotism does not equal racism," and "KKK stay out of New York" and "Nobody is illegal," were some favorites. So I went to check it out mainly in the interest of learning something and hearing from both sides of the immigration debate. To be frank, even though I view the Minutemen as racist xenophobes posing as patriots, I agree with their fundamental stance that the border should be better policed, though I doubt any wall or army or billions of dollars can ever fully stop the tide of immigrants. In the long run the only thing that will solve the "border problem" is higher standards of living in Mexico and Latin America, policies aimed at that goal are the only viable solution. There are an estimated 12 million illegal immigrants in the US. Millions living illegally, under the radar, invites intractable problems. I support open borders but that does not mean I support illegal immigration. Open borders must be managed and regulated and everyone must be documented. So, basically, I went in thinking maybe the Minutemen had a valid point.
So the event begins and out strolls the first speaker, a member of the MP board of directors, Marvin Stewart, a guy who thought he was MLK-caliber but made Don King look articulate. So the hecklers tore into him. The speakers rant droned on as he read long passages from the constitution and lectured us all on US history, many students stood up and turned their backs to the stage in silent protest. So about 45 minutes in, it starts to become a joke, it felt like we were watching a Saturday Night Live skit. The founder of the group, and presumably the head honcho, Jim Gilchrist, even came out on stage twice trying to get him to wrap it up and take a seat. But the guy refused to back down, emboldened by the hostile crowd and the natives gradually got more and more restless. Finally he finished and the group's founder Jim Gilchrist took the podium and I was hopeful that he would turn things around, maybe get some question and answer going. But instead he ran over and hugged Marvin Stewart as the Columbia faithful roared their disapproval booing and yelling, both of them taunting the crowd with giant grins and thumbs-up signs, revelling in the spotlight of so much hatred. Gilchrist then opened his speech with, "this is gonna be even more fun than the speech I had prepared," and then "excuse me" as he took a mock phone call from his wife and pretended to tell her that he was speaking to the biggest group of social maladroits he'd ever seen. The gloves were off, the hecklers were getting more childish and vicious and the head of the Minuteman Project was matching them blow for blow. Less than a minute in to his speech a group of students managed to get on stage with a sign that read, "Nadie es ilegal, Nobody is illegal." And, as if it was all orchestrated, all hell broke loose. 20 some students stormed the stage and flipped over the panelists table, punches were flying, a few quality kicks and the whole damn thing was shortly called off, and we all made our way outside where a crowd was triumphantly chanting, "el pueblo unido jamas sera vencido." So not a thing was learned about immigration, but a little civics lesson on violent activism and free speech and the Minutemen were sent packing, literally thrown off the stage. So the college kids were childish, and the speakers were too and the whole thing descended into chaos. The president of the College Republicans knew full well that you cannot invite two groups full of hatred for each other to come together, have a civil debate and not expect fireworks. The Columbia College Republicans wanted fireworks, they were looking for a fight and thats what they got. Columbia makes national news and now the College Republicans disingenuously cry foul, saying that Columbia students don't respect free speech and want to silence the opposition. For the Columbia reaction take a look at this article. And you can watch the video.
Bill O'Reilly even chimed in calling Columbia an ultra-left institution that should be called "Havana North," you can watch talking points here and go to "The Far Left Becomes Dangerous."
So what about free speech and responsible dissent? Grasping for a justification for the protestors actions I came up with the following. Four microphones were set up in the aisleways ostensibly for student questions and Q & A was advertised as part of the program, but one hour in, no questions had been fielded. To be fair, an hour is not very long. The Minutemen point to the stage-storming as proof that Columbia does not tolerate dissenting voices and does not value free speech. Obviously they are right, Columbia students silenced the opposition. But what remains of free speech if one side of the debate is free to monopolize the stage and the microphone? One might argue that it was the Minuteman Project's event, so of course they will have a disproportionate amount of floor time. A very good argument. Groups who oppose the Minutemen could presumably hold a parallel event or find ways to make their voices heard in outside venues. The protestors might counter with: "How can you practice 'responsible dissent' if you are not given a chance to speak? The Minutemen and College Republicans can righteously preach from the moral high ground, trumpeting free speech and saying they were attacked but they effectively silenced the opposition for as long as they could before Columbia students silenced them. So its 50-50." Try as I might, I cannot defend the protestors actions, it is not 50-50 and no matter how reprehensible their views and actions, it is an issue of free speech and free speech was trampled on Wednesday night. The protestors embarassed the univeristy and unfortunately, neither side was interested in meaningful debate and neither side was interested in listening, and nothing of any value came from the event.
Comments