National Security vs. The Public's Right to Know


The year was 1940 and Hitler and Mussolini's fascism was flooding across Europe. A war like no war before or since was raging. From a BBC office in London, war correspondent Edward R. Murrow gave nightly reports recounting the tragedy unfolding all around him. The Americans remembered the carnage of World War I and wanted no part in Europe's war and yet they tuned in by the millions to hear Murrow's voice each night, to hear of the air raids and bombings and horror of war - a war Murrow said he absolutely must cover "even if it kills me." At a black tie dinner the following was said to Murrow, "You laid the dead of London at our door and we knew that the dead were our dead, were mankind's dead. Without rhetoric, without dramatics, without more emotion than needed be, you have destroyed the superstition that what is done beyond 3000 miles of water is not really done at all." A year later, on December 7, 1941, the navy's total information blackout had kept the true scale of the bombing from the American People (some news outlets reported 7 dead and many injured), a seething FDR called Murrow into a White House room and told him every detail of the staggering numbers of dead and wounded brought by the surprise Japanese attack. Murrow went to sleep that night and told his wife, "I've got the greatest story of my life and I don't know if I should go with it or forget it." For 4 days Murrow did not write a word and the blackout was not broken, he felt it would have been unpatriotic and would have endangered the outcome of the war to have done so.
A war is a national purpose, and a noble war unites a nation. During World War II, every frame of newsreel, every radio broadcast, every written dispatch was reviewed by official censors and they held back anything they felt likely to damage morale at home or on the battlefield. Just as often, the reporters censored themselves. Defeat really was not an option, it was a war for national survival. Fundamentally public opinion wins wars. That does not mean you must support any and all American wars so we can win, but we should understand the influence of public opinion on a war effort.

In the 'police-action' wars of Korea, Vietnam and Iraq the military-press alliance began to show cracks. "Guidelines" to reporters replaced military censorship and stories began making their way to America, stories questioning military decisions, criticizing soldiers and generals and doubting whether the war could be won. When the resulting damage to the war effort became clear in Korea, the military again stepped in and re-instituted censorship. The cycle repeated itself in Vietnam, war reporters correspondence was not systematically censored initially, as the conflict gradually grew, the effects grew more and more devastating to the American cause. News coverage generated pivotal moments in the war, the self-immolation of a Buddhist monk, American troops burning the homes of Vietnamese women and children, a napalm burned Vietnamese girl running through the streets and the footage of the Tet Offensive showing chaos in the streets of Saigon led to a growing crisis of confidence in America, a crisis Walter Cronkite (the "Most trusted man in America") openly articulated on National television that was the beginning of the end for the American hope of victory. The stalemate in Korea and the loss of the Vietnam war were, at the very least, hastened by the turn of public opinion brought about by unfettered military coverage. And the Iraq war is now unwinnable because the bottom has fallen out of public opinion, mainly because we hear of the rising death toll every single day.

So does this mean Fox News, in being cheerleaders for the Bush Administration and the war effort are the true patriots? Are they helping America "win the war?" Does wartime justify censorship? Reagan thought so and blocked coverage of Grenada only to later be forced into a compromise, allowing limited press access. George H.W. Bush and the pentagon offered limited press access to news outlets during the Gulf War and created a new framework of rules, an ironclad web of restrictions (reporters were detained for trying to get a story without a military escort) aimed at guaranteeing that the liability posed by a free press seen in Vietnam would be kept in check in Iraq. Operation Desert Storm, in the eyes of the American public, made war noble and tidy again and the ghosts of Vietnam were vanquished. In response to new technology and the media uproar after the Gulf War, George W. Bush and his administration loosened the stranglehold and offered the "embedding" program, restrictions remained in place, accurate information was and is hard to come by, but live up-to-the-minute news coverage from the front lines makes it into the homes of Americans.

The press can only cover or not cover what actually happens, it is not the source of defeat and failure or victory and success, only the messenger. So war correspondents, news outlets and military overseers are left to balance national security and the public's right to know. How far should they go in sorting and bending the "facts"? How far should they go in delivering awful, unvarnished truths? Are they doing a service or a disservice to their country when they do so?
Depends on your politics I guess.

Comments

Anonymous said…
Yes, you are correct, public opinion can affect the outcome of a war. For the Vietnam war, America was losing bad. The Vietcong had a reason to fight, while America and their allies didn't. The American people did not want to be there. They had been protesting for almost a decade and finally there was enough pressure to pull out of a losing war. Public opinion made them pull out of the war, but did not make them lose the war.

Do you really think that if the American people supported the Iraq war, we would win? What does that mean to win the Iraq war? Will the people unite, form a beautiful democracy, and become born agains?


I dont think you can compare the Iraq and Vietnam wars to WW II.

OK, Papa Bear???

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China