Hydrogen Economy to be or not to be?


Politicians’ buzzwords like climate change, clean coal, renewable energy, dependence on foreign oil, “drill, baby drill" and "pain at the pump" are testament to the centrality of energy in the modern economy. Hydrogen, however, has gotten comparatively little airtime despite being clean, efficient and naturally abundant. According to the UN-affiliated International Center for Hydrogen Energy Technologies, hydrogen has the potential to “facilitate the transition to a low-carbon energy future, in a similar way that oil and the internal combustion engine displaced coal and the steam engine.” Despite such claims, there is great disagreement about hydrogen’s proper place in today’s energy policy. In January 2012 the world’s first hydrogen-powered autorickshaws hit the streets of New Delhi, the result of collaboration between the Indian Institute of Technology, a US energy company, the UN development agency and others. With many cities choked by pollution – India is 125th out of 132 countries in air qualityi and the world’s 3rd largest CO2 producer – the autorickshaws, which emit only water vapor, turned heads, raising the question; has the hydrogen economy arrived?

The Physics – The viability of the hydrogen economy lies at the intersection of public policy, economics and physics. Hydrogen (H2), per gram, has about 2½ times the energy potential of gasoline. But even when compressed, it is only 1/5 as dense. So a full tank of gasoline will take you twice as far as the same tank filled with hydrogen. As a gas, hydrogen is lighter than air, disperses quickly and tends to burn rather than explode, nevertheless the Hindenburg disaster stigmatized hydrogen as unsafe and while advances in compression technology to liquid hydrogen would improve miles per tank it would also increase explosiveness. While it is true that hydrogen is abundant, the vast majority is either bound up in fossil fuels, or with oxygen in water (think H2O) so electrolysis (passing electric current through water to separate hydrogen and oxygen) or some other technologyii is required. In other words, most ways to obtain hydrogen require another energy source and the high costs that entails, which is why, currently, hydrogen is not being produced for mass consumer use anywhere. While hydrogen itself may be “clean” the electrolysis which split the water to harvest hydrogen may have been created, for example, by a pollution-belching coal power plant. Therefore, conceptually, it makes sense to think of hydrogen not as an independent energy source like oil, but rather as an especially efficient means of storing energy.

The Economics – Hydrogen mass consumption infrastructure would require substantial outlays for production plants, a distribution network and hydrogen fueling stationsiii all of which, with current technology, are prohibitively expensive for the private sector unless oil prices remain consistently over $100/barrel. But if oil prices did stay that high, other cheaper energies would likewise become viable, such as coal gasification. So, with current technology, not only is the hydrogen as a “clean-energy” claim frequently misleading, hydrogen harvesting is relatively expensive, and even conservative estimates project America’s coal supply to last 200 years so the “energy security” argumentiv for hydrogen doesn’t pass economic muster either. That said, if water splitting to obtain hydrogen uses solar or wind energy, hydrogen becomes fully clean, albeit remanded to the coattails of other renewable energies. A square meter solar panel can only take in approximately the amount of energy required for a 100 watt light bulbv and, only 40% of that solar energy
can be turned into electrical power. In short, we can imagine a pollution-free future with solar-to-hydrogen or wind-to-hydrogen but bajillions of solar panels or windmills would be needed to power the nation. The prohibitive costs come with the caveat; ‘with current technology.’ If the technology improves and global demand and fuel prices rise inexorably, the hydrogen economy, and a whole universe of renewable energies, surges on to the viability horizon. So while the amount of global sunlight and wind and the physics of energy won’t change, the economics of energy are always in flux. For now, private sector hydrogen research is more exciting than profitable. With the enormous stakes in the energy-driven global economy, policymakers from New Delhi to Washington are left to guess at both long-term trends in energy markets and the pace of technological development and then make risk-reward assessments and check government coffers to decide whether to roll the dice and wager on the future of hydrogen.

Public Finance – Problems might include the principal-agent problem (caused by asymmetric info) because hydrogen researchers and firms might exaggerate the economic promise of hydrogen to win government funding. In addition moral hazard could occur as researchers might take greater risks on expensive technological schemes if not bearing the costs themselves. Furthermore hydrogen advocating interest groups might rent-seek for regulatory capture by advocating raising taxes on competing fossil fuels (perhaps a “carbon tax”) and promote alarmism about greenhouse gases and climate change. Safeguarding against such risks could involve signaling by requiring demonstration of viable models and detailed long-term development plans for hydrogen research and in-depth vetting of potential government funding recipients. Offering tax incentives, facilitating 3-way academic-industrial-government partnerships and developing in-house governmental expertise on the physics and economics of hydrogen could mitigate such risks.


Other References
1. The Guardian. The Ultimate Climate Change FAQ: What’s the hydrogen economy? http://www.guardian.co.uk/environment/2012/oct/11/hydrogen-economy-climate-change?newsfeed=true

2. Phys.org. Why a Hydrogen Economy Doesn’t Make Sense http://phys.org/news85074285.html

3. How Stuff Works. How the Hydrogen Economy Works by Marshall Brain. http://auto.howstuffworks.com/fuel-efficiency/fuel-economy/hydrogen-economy.htm

4. BBC. Hydrogen-powered passenger ferry to be trialled in Bristol. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-bristol-19870653

5. UC Berkeley Webcast. Physics for Future Presidents by Prof. Richard Muller. Lectures 1 and 2. http://zendiplomat.blogspot.com/2012/11/physics-for-future-presidents-uc.html

i According to 2012 Environmental Performance Index survey from Yale and Columbia Universities, air quality ranking includes “other environmental indicators.”
ii Other options include; chemical reactions, thermal decomposition by heating water to extreme temperatures (e.g. 2200° celsius) and depriving algae of sulfur and thereby corrupting normal photosynthesis to produce hydrogen instead of oxygen.
iii Air Products, a Pennsylvania-based energy company provided the single re-fueling station in New Delhi for the 15 autorickshaws currently in operation. Vehicles hook up to pumps and hoses with special nozzles similar to compressed natural gas delivery.
iv the US could produce plenty of hydrogen domestically
v which should make sense given comparable amounts of light/heat


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China