Review of Chirot & McCauley's Why Not Kill Them All? The Logic and Prevention of Mass Political Murder

“Fight in the cause of Allah against those who fight you but do not transgress limits; Allah does not love those who transgress limits...if they fight you, kill them...but if they stop, then Allah is most forgiving and merciful...if they cease hostilities, there can be no [further] hostility.” -Quran, Sura 2:190

Authors' Backgrounds
Daniel Chirot is a University of Washington professor of sociology who specializes in genocide, ethno-religious conflict and political sociology focusing on Eastern Europe. Clark McCauley is a Bryn Mawr College professor of social psychology who specializes in the psychology of group identification, intergroup conflict, ethnic conflict, terrorism and genocide. Chirot has worked as a consultant for the Ford Foundation, USAID and the National Endowment for Democracy and is an expert on conflict mitigation in West Africa where he has initiated civil society projects. McCauley, after 9/11, renewed his interest in terrorism and was supported by the Department of Homeland Security through the National Consortium for Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism (START) for six years. This book review will summarize the ideas in the book Why Not Kill Them All? and offer concluding commentary.
Defining Genocide?
Article 6 of the Rome Statute (2002) of the International Criminal Court (ICC) defines genocide as: “a manifest pattern of conduct...with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group” including “(a) Killing members of the group, (b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; (c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part; (d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group; (e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group”
One of the authors' innovations is moving beyond such a definition template which differentiates genocide from warfare. Instead, for Chirot and McCauley (C&M), violent intergroup conflicts exist on a continuum of acts of war and can degenerate into dehumanization of the enemy, ethnic cleansing and to the extreme of genocide (i.e. unlimited mass political murder). Genocide is planned and directed, or at least approved, by authorities with a “justified” goal and deliberately carried out by ingroup members. Additionally, it is not the numbers killed that defines the phenomenon but “killing [non-combatants] by category – because of their membership in a group rather than by individual guilt or crime” (p. 81). In C&M's open definition, “killing” is equated with “causing death,” thereby incorporating the 1830s Cherokee removal in the southeastern US (a.k.a. The Trail of Tears) which killed by exposure, disease and starvation as well as the Irish potato famine of the 1840s in which Brits “killed” Irish by deliberate neglect, as cases of genocide. C&M bring ethnic cleansing (partial or limited genocide) and ethnic riots (protogenocides that are too disorganized to kill large numbers) into the same analytical frame because the emotions and fear are similar. Both a deep sense of historical injustice based on group identifications1 and a proximate trigger such as an economic or political crisis (e.g. general breakdown in law and order and state protections), reminders of humiliations, murder, rape or rumors of them) are usually required for genocide to occur.
Four Motives of Genocide
C&M assert “the specific reasoning behind each [case of genocide] needs to be analytically disentangled in order to understand why they took place” (p. 44), and outline 4 motives for genocide:
  1. Instrumental – Conflict over territory, resources or control of an unconquerable or unmanageable group that is targeted for elimination to get them out of the way (i.e. a genocide of convenience like the Cherokee removal and many colonial conquests).
  2. Fear of Enemy – Conflict with a rival power group that is feared, threatening and/or may retaliate. Most powerful fear is the fear that our people, cause, culture, and history will become extinct, which elicits the most violent and extreme reactions and “justifies” ruthless extermination in “self-defense” to save us (almost all genocides have some element of fear).
  3. Revenge – Conflict based on the emotional satisfaction of retribution against a perceived implacable and hate-filled enemy group for historical grievances. Purpose can be upholding ingroup honor or deterring future attacks (i.e. if we show any weakness or compromise we will encourage more attacks so we must brutally punish enemies like the Ancient Romans or Netanyahu's Likud Party today).
  4. Purification from Pollution – Conflict based on belief that ingroup society must be purified to save its essence by purging contaminating group members. Involves disgust and hatred of enemy, often portraying target group members as a disease, or as pigs, rats, maggots, cockroaches, monsters, beasts, demons or with tails, horns, hooves, pointed ears, etc. Targets' contamination is a matter of inherent essence that cannot be changed (i.e. a cockroach can never become clean). To rally Nazi “purification” of the “Jewish disease” Hitler wrote “with satanic joy in his face, the black-haired Jewish youth lurks in waiting for the unsuspecting girl whom he defiles with his blood, thus stealing her from her people. With every means he tries to destroy the racial foundations of the people he has set out to subjugate” (p. 42). The Old Testament also speaks of justified war to prevent miscegenation. C&M differentiate anger (characteristic of revenge), a temporary, aggressive emotion caused by insult, pain or frustration and hatred (characteristic of purification) which combine contempt, disgust, anger, fear into a steady, enduring evaluative orientation towards the essence of some group, becoming sadistic.
The above motives for genocide should not be seen as mutually exclusive and often are mixed. For example, Stalin's genocide of anti-communists was instrumental in eliminating uncontrollable and feared political opposition while purifying society from the pollution of corrupt ideologies. Another example, it is rumored that Hitler got syphilis from a Jewish prostitute, thereby motivating revenge against pollution. In general, perpetrators of genocide believe killing is the right thing to do, i.e. they view their genocide as justified. A prerequisite of killing by category is collective blame which requires essentialization. Essentializing is imagining any social group (ingroup or outgroup) as a pure monolith inherently defined by its essence (i.e. spirit, personality, etc.). This is the aspect that is most concerning because essentializing or stereotyping is part of normal human conceptual economy. In times of intense tension or threat, there emerges a “narcissism of minor differences,” where those who differ only slightly from the ingroup prototype are punished or ostracized as threats to group purity – thereby emphasizing strict group boundaries (the McCarthyite Red Scare, witch hunts or Pol Pot's purges were extra venomous because contaminants could “camouflage themselves and blend in to the group.” This concept is why the Nazis needed to mark Jews with the Star of David). Finally, genocides depend on a great power differential between the ingroup and the target outgroup.
The Psychology of War and Genocide
The good vs. evil theory, that evil, sadistic, maniacs have been the cause of genocides, has been replaced by the notion that ordinary, sane men can commit insane heinous acts. Indeed, C&M consider WWII to have degenerated into a contagious frenzy of genocides because many nations saw their very survival at stake. A March 1944 survey of 4,064 US infantrymen with combat experience fighting the Japanese asked: “What would you like to see happen to the Japanese after the war?” 43% said “Punish leaders but not ordinary Japanese.” 9% said “Make Japanese people suffer plenty.” 43% said “Wipe out the whole Japanese nation.” A survey months earlier showed 61% in favor of wiping out the whole Japanese nation (p. 184). Another survey asked: “When the going was tough, how much were you helped by thoughts of hatred for the enemy?” 46% said thoughts of hatred for the enemy “helped a lot.” The point is not that Americans or American soldiers were bloodthirsty or hate-filled – the assumption is that other nations' soldiers had proportional sentiments towards their enemies – but that it is sometimes hard to distinguish the psychology of war from the psychology of genocide.
Becoming a Killer
How do ordinary men become killers? Killing in self-defense is near-universally seen as morally legitimate but killing anyone for any reason still disgusts non-killers, more so depending on the method and amount of blood, body parts, etc. the killer is exposed to. SS Chief Himler supposedly vomited the first time he witnessed Jews being massacred at his death camps (gas chambers were an innovation from mass shootings, designed to reduce disgust by adding distance, hiding victims from sight and reducing blood, etc. Nevertheless, Nazi executioners reportedly drank copious amounts of alcohol to diminish their disgust in killing and moving bodies). C&M say that military and genocide leaders must deal with both their subordinates' disgust at killing and their perceptions of the moral legitimacy of kills, especially killing of unarmed civilians that present no threat. Overcoming the reluctance to kill is called “dissonance theory.” Dissonance is the body's chemical reaction (negative arousal) when we do something at odds with our self-image, the less outside pressure was imposed on us to commit the act, the greater the dissonance. We, killers included, generally deal with this dissonance by changing our beliefs about what is right and wrong to accommodate our behavior and relieve dissonance. Military training ritualizes and routinizes killing while appealing to cadet's sense of duty, manhood and emotions of fear, anger, and hatred of the enemy, possibly drawing on past humiliation or injustices suffered at hands of the enemy (e.g. “Remember the Alamo” as a vengeful battle cry). In short, with training and experience, many normal individuals can become killers – desensitized to death and brought to see their killing as morally legitimate.
Leading Followers
C&M emphasize that genocidal leaders typically perceive credible personal threats that are more direct and immediate than threats perceived by followers. Leaders mobilize followers by playing up threats, sometimes reminding followers of past negative experiences with enemy, threatening followers for disobedience, provoking the enemy into acts that confirm the threat, etc. The successful leader thereby increases his own popularity and powers, essentializes and idealizes ingroup values, essentializes the outgroup (called “double essentializing”), raises group solidarity (a.k.a. cohesion, patriotism, nationalism) and raises willingness to punish deviates from ingroup norms. It may be tempting to imagine leader's rhetoric to be bogus Machiavellian manipulation masking the urge to money and power, C&M argue that leader's manifest sincere belief in their rhetoric is key to inspiring followers.
Obedience to Authority
The 1960s “learning experiments” of social psychologist Stanley Milgram illuminate the psychological evolution of ordered killing by studying obedience to authority. Milgram's subjects were ordered by an authority figure (a confederate of Milgram) to administer, what they believed to be, increasing electric shocks (+15 volts each time up to 450 volts) to another “student subject” (a confederate of Milgram/actor who was not being shocked but screaming and feigning pain). The shocks were punishment for each wrong answer the “student” gave to the authority figure's questions. 2/3rds of Milgram's subjects went “all the way” to 450 volts even when the “student victim” of the shocks (who was audible but not visible) repeatedly screamed in pain, asked to quit the study, and then fell completely silent at the highest levels of shocks. By incrementally raising the shock levels, Milgram created a slippery slope – a rationalization feedback loop in his subjects. Administering the first shock creates minor cognitive dissonance which can be relatively easily rationalized. This first rationalization helps justify the second shock administration behavior which is then rationalized, enabling the next higher level shock, all the way up to 450 volts, where silence of the shocked subject could only have been interpreted as death.2 C&M postulate the following analogous psychological slippery slope of a genocide perpetrator, with each action reinforcing the rationalization of the next “I have been ordered to do this; those being killed are doing something wrong; they stand in my way; they deserve it; they are a threat to my own people; they are not quite human; they are polluting” (p. 53).
Were They All Nazis?
Was centuries-old, popular anti-semitism behind Nazi genocide? Or was anti-semitism mild and not genocidal until the Nazi period? Or is it that the Nazi genocide neither had nor needed widespread popular support or deep structural causes but was primarily the work of a small group of ideologues who seized power? To what extent did humiliation from WWI and ongoing economic desperation enable Hitler's rise and the subsequent genocide? To what degree can Hitler's popularity be separated from his genocidal ambitions? How similar is the Nazi genocide (the most studied by far) to other genocides in terms of popular internalization? These questions cannot be definitively answered but C&M speculate that long-held views about ethnic, religious, class or regional groups matter as do extremist leaders. They cite German intellectuals' writings on the need for German redemption through purification (i.e. elimination of Jews) and the lack of protests or disloyalty to Hitler to argue “popular historical mythologies of ethnicity and nation are conducive to the triumph of extremism” (p. 176).
Why is Limited Warfare More Common than Genocide?
As discussed earlier, killing is generally repulsive to socialized individuals, it also reminds us of our own mortality which adds stress. But if military training can effectively desensitize warriors and ideological and emotional retribalization can legitimize killing, then why are there not more genocides? In pre-state societies, large-scale killing was rare and highly ritualized combat with occasional killings was more common. C&M look through history at examples of intergroup practices such as gift-giving or exchange, ritualized daughter-giving or exchange for marriage, commercial exchange as well as communication between leaders, and intergroup agreement on rules of violent conflict (chivalric codes) as mitigators of war on enemy outgroups. Such exchanges require repeated interaction/communication and a shadow of the future. Additionally, C&M cite self-referential group codes of honor against torture or slaughtering women and children. The basic cost-benefit analysis that war, in general, risks very high costs also contributes to mitigating violent conflict. Finally, intergroup relations are reciprocally determined – peace begets peace – so, where enabled, it was usually more efficient and rational to avoid a zero-sum confrontation by compromising and living peacefully with other groups or in isolation from them. But with metal and increasingly lethal weapons as well as supra-tribal, socially stratified chiefdoms and eventually states, great intergroup power differentials emerged that lowered the risks of violence, especially for leaders now removed from the battlefield, and raised the rewards (e.g. resource and slave capture). C&M argue that while many of these ancient practices are gone and social structures have changed, the basic psychology has not. Therefore, today, any rule-bound intergroup exchange can help prevent or at least limit the severity of violent intergroup conflict, as can agreed upon chivalric codes, today embodied through international treaties, conventions and laws.
Is Enlightenment Individualism the Solution?
The C&M mantra throughout the book is that Enlightenment values of individualism, including democracy and capitalism, are the key to prevention of genocide, because “Anti-individualistic, strongly communitarian ideologies3 when combined with utopian certitude and an exalted sense of mission, led to the worst genocidal conflicts of the 20th century” (p. 86). C&M agree with Adam Smith and Joseph Schumpeter that capitalism is inherently peaceful. Markets and peaceful trade, rather than conquest or honor – the argument goes – changed the zero-sum intergroup default mentality to a positive sum mentality for relations based on commercial gain. This is nothing more than a continuation of the idea above that rule-based intergroup exchange promotes peace. To be clear, C&M do not argue that a democratic capitalist nation-state is incapable of genocide – by their definition the US firebombing of Germany and nuclear bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki were genocidal – merely that such an economic system, and its corresponding individualistic values, reduce the likelihood. They point to 16th century differences between the ideologically driven, conquering-and-enslaving Spanish and the uniquely mercantile Dutch with their East India Company. Though both the Spanish and the Dutch fought many wars, the Spanish were more likely to massacre (a higher % of combatants on both sides were killed) and fight long wars whereas Dutch mercantile values had replaced the values of honor and loyalty, so Dutch wars were shorter and more limited. In today's modern world, higher literacy rates, ease of communications, mass media and advanced military training can be harnessed by states with vast resources to mobilize tribal passions against malevolent, “monolithic” enemy groups, upping the ante, along with advanced weaponry, for unlimited intergroup violence. In short, C&M answer with a qualified yes, that modern capitalist societies are less prone to genocide, therefore “enlightenment glorification of the individual and individual rights is more important than ever, and necessary to restrain genocidal impulses” (p. 123).
To the question; Are we doomed by our human nature to slaughter each other? C&M would say that while the holocaust is popularly remembered as proof of normal people's inborn potential for ethnic hatred and animal savagery, or at best the cowardice of those Germans who stood by and did nothing, such pessimism is excessive. “As a species we have a dual nature. We are competitive and warlike to the point of being murderous, sometimes even genocidal, but we also long for peace and are conciliatory and cooperative.” C&M contend that competing groups usually find ways of controlling and managing conflicts and emotions – the Cuban Missile Crisis for example which led to a Moscow-Washington hotline – but that catastrophic failure of such mechanisms is still possible.
Prevention Strategies
C&M conclude their book discussing four types of extant strategies to decrease the chances of mass political murder and offering their recommendations to make them more effective, stressing that intrastate conflicts are more likely than interstate today:
1. C&M Typology of State Level Policies Toward Internal Minorities – Tolerant States can practice a) Inclusion through gentle assimilation like France today, b) Distinction through multiculturalism like the USA or UK today, c) Exclusion through voluntary separation like Czechs and Slovaks or emigration like the US back-to-Africa Liberia experiment. Intolerant States can practice a) Inclusion through forced assimilation like Turkish policy towards the Kurds, b) Distinction through segregation like the US post-Civil-War south or apartheid South Africa, c) Exclusion through population transfer, ethnic cleansing or genocide like the Native American removal, Ottoman elimination of Armenians, Yugoslavia break-up or the Nazi holocaust of Jews.
C&M advocate tolerant distinction in the form of federalism as a type of multiculturalism, citing India as a multiethnic model, that gives regional/ethnic group autonomy and co-opts group elites into a state political structure.
2. Global Criminal Justice – The British, Soviets and US did not enter WWII to stop the genocide of the Jews but to save themselves. The liberation of ghastly Nazi death camps, however, shocked the conscience of humanity in Western democracies and, with the Nuremberg trials, the impetus international criminal justice reached critical mass, at least in theory. The 2002 creation of a permanent international Criminal Court (ICC) aspired to universal jurisdiction over individual leaders (not states) that would end immunity for the most heinous war crimes. However, C&M stress the deficiencies of such a system which still; a) upholds state sovereignty, thereby nullifying hopes of universal jurisdiction, b) has struggled to define crimes and self-defense in a way that will be perceived as globally legitimate and unbiased towards Western interests and c) has only enforced its jurisdiction on individuals in weak African states which is perceived as unfair.
3. Truth and Reconciliation Commissions (TRCs) – Widespread agreement that 'Victor's Justice' on Germany after WWI contributed to Hitler's rise stopped mass punishment after WWII in favor of minimal punishments or amnesties and state-led amnesia of the horrors of war because peace, reconciliation and reconstruction trumped the need for justice. C&M examine different ways to promote reconciliation between former enemy groups. Contact-based peace programs (e.g. face-to-face “citizen diplomacy” encounters between ordinary people from post-conflict groups, like those the NGO Seeds of Peace organizes) or cross-cultural dialogue initiatives may create personal friendships that undermine outgroup essentialization, but they do not deal with underlying sources of animosity and usually only reach small minorities of each group. Political peace negotiations, like the 1979 Camp David Treaty between Egypt and Israel, can ignore enduring intergroup hostility. C&M instead champion development of civil society groups as the necessary connector of top-down political processes to bottom-up initiatives. Only representative local community leaders and their organizational media/output can reach the masses, in turn those leaders must have rule-based forums (autonomous regional orgs) to come together and discuss and plan cooperative initiatives. Such forums must be integrated into, and supported by, the vertical political structure, which itself must effectively protect minority rights, if there is to be deep and meaningful democracy.
4. Enlightenment Individualism – To be promoted by the state and international institutions.
Conclusion
As C&M convincingly illustrate, violent intergroup conflict is here to stay. Ethnic and national identities and loyalties remain strong almost everywhere. Even if scholars insist such communities are imagined, constructed, fabricated, as Ernest Renan said “a nation is a group of people united by a mistaken view about the past and a hatred of their neighbors” – perception is 9/10ths of reality. Scholars will never talk people out of their group identities, which are problematic. Martin Jaffee points out, “many would like to say that Abrahamic religions of Judaism, Christianity and Islam are compatible with each other, believe in the same God and emerged from the same region and cultural tradition. But all three monotheisms are framed as a moral imperative to transform a historical community in a project of divine service...any group that resists God's will can easily be seen as the kind of threat and pollution we have found associated with mass killing” (p. 182). Marty and Appleby (1994) conclude that the monotheisms are particularly well-suited to inspire fundamentalism because they are master narrative religions of ancient books. The Old Testament and Mein Kampf have much more in common than the Western world is comfortable acknowledging. In the modern world, rapid social change and failed or failing states can intensify suffering, competition for scarce resources, etc. which can increase the appeal of ideologies that promise salvation. C&M want us to remember the normality of mass murder, citing Steven Pinker, “it is the belief that [mass] violence is an aberration that is dangerous, because it lulls us into forgetting how easily violence may erupt in quiescent places” (p. 184).
Commentary
C&M present a compelling and insightful explanation of genocide. In particular, their advocacy of building civil society institutions seems spot on. But civil society is so widely supported that it has become nearly synonymous with development so this is not revolutionary. Several of C&Ms' key conclusions evidence ethnocentric bias. Their most vigorous claim, as enlightened individualists themselves, is that such values are superior. This sounds disturbingly similar to ideological superiority arguments of the genocideers they condemn (e.g. Stalin, Pol Pot, Mao). Furthermore, as C&M note, “When the United States or Great Britain, or any other post-Enlightenment Western nation committed genocidal acts on populations, they did so by rejecting Enlightenment political philosophy” (p. 141). But if such enlightened nations can, in the heat of war, reject Enlightenment ideals of individual rights, then spreading such ideals through education of the “social base” seems an ineffective strategy for preventing mass political murder. Besides, enlightenment individualism is powerful (as C&M argue to thwart essentializing or stereotyping) within the US in justifying multiculturalism but it seems doubtful that such values can translate into American appreciation and valuation of the diversity of over 1 billion Muslims or over 1 billion Chinese. Diversity is hardly popularly appreciated in the distant abstract. I personally share enlightenment individualist values but not pushing them on others. Rigid, “superior” ideology is the problem. Instead, any solution must be procedural and systemic, that is, like the creation of a Moscow-Washington hotline, broad and open channels of regular communication with “enemies” (for the USA, this includes communicating with Al Qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, the Taliban, Iran, North Korea, Venezuela, Cuba, Syria, etc.), the ratification and improved enforcement of global criminal justice treaties, tailored-design of post-conflict TRCs and above all else increased intercultural exchange in terms of trade, travel, tourism, technical and academic exchange/cooperation, etc. In other words, we do not have to all embrace the same ideology we just need to keep talking to each other and not storm away from table in anger – we must know each other and actively pursue understanding of each other.
In the same vein C&M condemn collectivism as dangerously prone to ingroup-outgroup essentializing and mobilization for violence. But the majority of mankind is of collectivist cultures and the two most murderous wars the world has ever seen raged in the European heart of “enlightened individualism” so they're argument is unconvincing and ethnocentrically self-serving. C&M similarly condemn the French minority assimilationist model of communitarisation in favor of US-style multiculturalism because it elevates individual minority rights over the collective. As Jewish-American intellectual elites, this may seem natural to C&M but, though Americans are proud of it, there is little evidence that the US multiculturalist model has proven substantially more successful than the French model of dealing with diversity.
Finally, C&M's dire warning about the fundamentalist potential of the monotheistic creeds – that we must remain ever-vigilant against – is correct on its face but it ignores the modern reality that the vast majority of self-identifying monotheists do not interpret their holy books literally. What determines which adherents become fundamentalist and which do not is sociological, psychological and cultural not religious. C&M again sound dangerously close to essentializing religions as fundamentally prone to violence which can easily feed into, for example, virulent popular Islamophobia in America. Monotheist scriptures also have countervailing messages that limit warfare, like at the beginning of this paper, and messages that encourage cross-cultural exchange and other-knowledge like the one below. As George Bernard Shaw said “No man ever believes the Bible means what it says: he is always convinced that it says what he means.” It is the same with all holy books and ideologies, they are tools used for human and group purposes, and according to their creeds we are all descended from the same pair and that notion of our common membership in one human family, if it could be internalized, might be among the greatest safeguards against genocide.
“O people, O humanity, O mankind we created you from a man and a woman and we have made you into peoples and tribes that you may know one another.” -Quran, Sura 49:13
“Until the philosophy which holds one race superior and another inferior is finally and permanently discredited and abandoned: That until there are no longer first-class and second-class citizens of any nation; That until the color of a man's skin is of no more significance than the color of his eyes; That until the basic human rights are equally guaranteed to all without regard to race; That until that day, the dream of lasting peace and world citizenship and the rule of international morality will remain but a fleeting illusion, to be pursued but never attained...and everywhere is war.” Haile Sellasie I/Bob Marley


1Video of Egyptian President Muhammad Mursi recently surfaced, of him urging Egyptians to nurse their children on hatred of Zionists, to make them feel past humiliations. Israeli schools stress victimhood. The Arabs and Israelis have competing narratives of righteous victimhood.
2When the “shock administering” subject hesitated to administer a shock, the authority figure would repeat “the study demands that you continue” until the subject administered the next shock or adamantly refused to do so.
3C&M are referring primarily to the Communism of Stalin and Pol Pot and the Fascism of Hitler.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ping-pong or an arms race with China?

Passionate Argentine Populism and the Enduring Legacy of Peronism

Go EAST Young Man! Teach English in China